When launching a new product or add-on module, is it better to upsell it as a paid add-on to existing customers or bundle it into a higher pricing tier? How do you determine the price of a new offering relative to your current products?

Below is a summary answer based on the insights provided in our pricing strategy book, Price to Scale:

Direct Answer
There is no one-size-fits-all answer. Whether you upsell a new product or bundle it in a higher tier depends on your customer segments, the specific value the offering adds, and how entrenched current pricing expectations are among your users.
Upsell as a Paid Add-on vs. Bundling into a Higher Tier
• Upsell as a Paid Add-on:
– This works well when the new feature or product addresses a discrete problem that only a subset of your customers requires.
– It enables you to capture incremental value without forcing all customers to upgrade, which may limit resistance from those not needing the added capabilities.
– As our book explains, the upsell process, especially when managed by dedicated account managers (the “farmer” role), takes a naturally incremental approach to revenue growth.
• Bundle into a Higher Pricing Tier:
– This is effective when the new functionality strongly complements your core offering and is likely to be embraced by customers who already expect more comprehensive solutions.
– Bundling may simplify the buying process for some segments and can drive higher average selling prices overall, but caution is needed since current customers might balk if the new tiers represent a significant jump from what they pay today.
Determining the Price of a New Offering
• Relative Value:
– Analyze how much additional value the new offering provides compared to your current features.
– Use frameworks like the modular or good–better–best approach (as detailed in our book) to map distinct features to corresponding price points.
• Customer Segmentation:
– Segment your existing customer base by usage patterns and willingness to pay.
– Consider that customers who currently use lightweight features might be better served by an add-on option, while heavy users might appreciate the bundled premium tier.
• Impact on Revenue and Relationships:
– Evaluate whether raising list prices (e.g., by upgrading customers to a premium tier) might risk alienating current clients, especially if the jump is steep.
– Alternatively, a thoughtfully priced add-on can capture additional revenue without forcing a dramatic change in your pricing structure.
Practical Application
– Run controlled experiments with pilot groups to test customer response to both an upsell add-on and a bundled premium package.
– Monitor metrics such as adoption rate, customer satisfaction, and overall revenue impact before scaling your approach company-wide.
Summary Takeaway
In our book Price to Scale, we advocate for a tailored approach: when launching a new product or module, base the method—whether as a paid add-on or a bundled tier—on the distinct needs and value perceptions of your customer segments. Carefully evaluate the incremental value, assess how it aligns with existing packages, and ensure that pricing changes enhance overall customer relationships without causing undue friction.

By aligning your strategy with these principles, you can optimize both revenue growth and customer satisfaction.

Get Started with Pricing-as-a-Service

Join companies like Zoom, DocuSign, and Twilio using our systematic pricing approach to increase revenue by 12-40% year-over-year.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.