Below is our answer based on the insights from our pricing strategy book, Price to Scale:
• Yes, there are cases where companies have intentionally priced their product above an established competitor—and succeeded. For example, our book highlights how companies (like the one discussed in the Amplitude Pricing Plan Evolution section) recognized that many customers were willing to pay a premium once the product’s unique value was clearly communicated.
• The key to convincing customers that a higher-priced product is worth it is to clearly differentiate your offering:
Enhanced Functionality & Quality: Mitigate direct price comparisons by ensuring that your product offers additional or advanced functionalities that matter to customers. When your product fulfills needs that a competitor’s lower-priced solution doesn’t—be it through innovative features, better performance, or improved support—it justifies the higher cost.
Communicating Value Proposition: Clearly articulate how the premium price translates into tangible benefits (such as increased productivity, better user experience, or long-term cost savings). Customers are more receptive when they understand that the price premium is an investment in superior quality or additional capabilities.
Targeting Willingness-to-Pay: Often a segment of the market is willing to pay more for a more complete solution once the product has been refined and the brand has achieved recognition. Our book suggests that through iterative market learning, as shown by pricing evolution cases, companies discover that many customers value enhanced features and are ready to upgrade to a premium plan.
• The takeaway is that intentionally pricing above competitors works when you have a clear strategy that enhances perceived value. This involves not only product differentiation but also transparent, customer-focused communication that outlines why the higher price is a worthwhile investment.
In summary, as discussed in our pricing strategy book, Price to Scale, success in charging a higher price than an established competitor hinges on demonstrably superior functionality and strategic communication that confirms the enhanced value to potential customers.