At what point should we consider removing or restricting our free plan because it’s not converting users to paid (or because it’s costly to support so many free users)?

Based on the principles outlined in our SaaS pricing strategy book, Price to Scale, you should consider removing or restricting your free plan when its cost structure and conversion metrics no longer justify its existence. Here are the key factors to evaluate:

  1. Conversion Rates vs. Support Costs
    If your free plan is not converting users to paid accounts at a rate that offsets the expense of supporting a large volume of free users, it becomes a clear signal to reassess the model. As discussed in Price to Scale, understanding the balance between free user acquisition and the cost to provide support is critical.

  2. Impact on Product Development
    Our book emphasizes that the freemium model should ideally drive product development toward features that entice free users to upgrade. When you notice that your free plan is not serving as a stepping stone to paid tiers—either because it attracts low-value users or because the burden on support teams detracts from premium feature focus—it might be time to pivot.

  3. Cost Analysis
    Regularly review your operational costs, such as the resources required to implement and support free users. If you observe a significant mismatch—where the cost to support free users exceeds the long-term revenue they potentially bring in—it’s prudent to consider restricting or even eliminating the free plan.

  4. Strategic Planning and Experimentation
    Before making any drastic changes, consider testing adjustments like feature limitations, usage caps, or shifting some benefits only to paid users. Use these experiments to evaluate if changes positively impact the conversion rate and overall support costs.

In summary, you should consider removing or restricting your free plan when the cost of supporting free users significantly outweighs the benefits of user acquisition and conversion to paid plans. The key takeaway from Price to Scale is to continuously monitor these metrics and pivot your strategy when the free model stops aligning with your broader growth and operational objectives.

Get Started with Pricing-as-a-Service

Join companies like Zoom, DocuSign, and Twilio using our systematic pricing approach to increase revenue by 12-40% year-over-year.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.