.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
In the competitive and rapidly evolving SaaS landscape, pricing strategy stands as one of the most powerful levers for improving profitability and growth. Yet paradoxically, while SaaS executives meticulously optimize product features, marketing campaigns, and sales processes, pricing experimentation remains curiously neglected. According to research by OpenView Partners, less than 30% of SaaS companies conduct regular pricing experiments, despite pricing improvements having the potential to increase revenue by 4-10% with minimal additional costs. This article explores why SaaS firms consistently under-invest in pricing experimentation and what forward-thinking executives can do to capture this overlooked opportunity.
The Power of Pricing: An Underutilized Lever
Patrick Campbell, founder of ProfitWell (now Paddle), famously noted that "a 1% improvement in pricing yields an average 11% increase in profit" - a leverage effect unmatched by improvements in customer acquisition costs, retention, or feature development. Despite this compelling math, pricing strategies in many SaaS organizations remain static for years, treated as an occasional project rather than an ongoing discipline.
The traditional approach of setting prices based on competitors' published rates or internal cost-plus calculations leaves significant value on the table. In contrast, systematic pricing experimentation reveals actual customer willingness to pay across different segments, features, packaging options, and go-to-market approaches.
The Six Barriers to Pricing Experimentation
Why do SaaS firms hesitate to experiment with their pricing when the potential returns are so substantial? Several barriers consistently emerge:
1. The Risk Perception Paradox
Many executives view pricing changes as inherently risky, fearing customer backlash or churn. This perception persists despite evidence suggesting the opposite. A study by Simon-Kucher & Partners found that well-designed pricing experiments actually reduce risk by providing data-driven validation before full-scale implementation.
"The irony is that not experimenting with pricing is often riskier than doing so," notes Kyle Poyar, Partner at OpenView. "Without experimentation, companies make major pricing decisions based on anecdotes, intuition, or competitive benchmarking - all of which can lead to leaving money on the table or misaligning with customer value perception."
2. Organizational Ownership Challenges
Pricing often falls into an organizational no-man's land. Is it Product's responsibility? Marketing's? Finance's? Sales'? This ambiguity leads to collective inaction. According to research by Profitwell, companies with a dedicated pricing function or clear ownership achieve 30% higher revenue growth than those without.
3. Technical Implementation Complexities
Many SaaS platforms weren't built with pricing experimentation in mind. Billing systems, CRMs, and product architectures often make it technically challenging to run different pricing scenarios simultaneously or segment customers effectively for pricing tests.
4. The Methodology Knowledge Gap
Effective pricing experimentation requires specialized knowledge. Unlike A/B testing webpage elements, pricing experiments demand statistical rigor, careful customer segmentation, and thoughtful implementation to avoid contamination effects or negative customer experiences.
A 2022 study by Paddle revealed that 68% of SaaS executives rate their team's pricing expertise as "inadequate" or "needing improvement," highlighting a critical capability gap.
5. Short-term Revenue Pressure
SaaS companies facing quarterly targets may hesitate to experiment with pricing when results could potentially reduce short-term conversion rates, even if the long-term revenue impact would be positive. This creates a persistent bias toward maintaining the status quo.
6. Cultural Resistance to Price Optimization
Many founders and product leaders built their companies with a focus on product value and customer experience. There's often a cultural resistance to what is sometimes perceived as "extracting more money" from customers, despite the fact that proper pricing is fundamentally about aligning price with delivered value.
Overcoming the Barriers: Building Pricing as a Core Competency
Forward-thinking SaaS executives are beginning to recognize pricing experimentation as a critical business discipline requiring deliberate investment. Here's how market leaders are transforming their approach:
Establish Clear Pricing Ownership
Companies like Slack, HubSpot, and Atlassian have established dedicated pricing teams or clear ownership frameworks that span product, marketing, and finance. This cross-functional approach ensures pricing receives proper attention while incorporating diverse perspectives.
Invest in Pricing Technology and Infrastructure
Modern pricing tools like ProfitWell, Chargebee, and Chargify enable more flexible experimentation. Additionally, leading companies are investing in custom infrastructure that allows for granular price testing without disrupting existing customers.
According to Patrick Campbell, "The companies winning on pricing have invested in infrastructure that makes pricing changes and experiments as easy as changing a marketing headline."
Adopt Incremental, Low-Risk Approaches
Rather than dramatic pricing overhauls, successful companies implement a continuous series of smaller tests:
- Testing pricing on new customer segments only
- Experimenting with add-on features before core offering changes
- Using cohort-based approaches rather than randomized trials
- Focusing initially on expansion revenue opportunities
Develop Internal Pricing Expertise
Leading SaaS companies are building pricing competency through training, hiring specialists, and partnering with pricing consultancies for knowledge transfer - treating pricing as a critical business capability rather than a periodic project.
The Competitive Advantage of Pricing Excellence
Companies that overcome these barriers gain significant advantages. According to data from OpenView's SaaS Benchmarks Survey, businesses that conduct regular pricing experiments achieve:
- 30% higher net dollar retention
- 25% faster growth rates
- 20% higher valuations
Stripe, for example, attributes a significant portion of its growth to continuous pricing refinement across its product portfolio, experimenting with different pricing models for different user segments based on their value perception and usage patterns.
HubSpot's evolution from a single product with straightforward pricing to a sophisticated platform with multiple products, packaging options, and tiered pricing demonstrates how pricing experimentation can support product-led growth and market expansion.
Building Your Pricing Experimentation Roadmap
To begin capturing the opportunity of pricing experimentation, consider this progressive approach:
Start with diagnosis: Analyze your current pricing strategy, identifying potential gaps with customer willingness to pay across segments.
Build the capability: Establish clear ownership, basic infrastructure, and knowledge to run simple pricing experiments.
Begin with low-hanging fruit: Test packaging options, feature differentiation, or expansion opportunities with new customers first.
Measure comprehensively: Look beyond conversion rates to lifetime value, expansion revenue, and retention when evaluating experiments.
Scale and systematize: Eventually develop a regular cadence of pricing experiments as a core business practice.
Conclusion: The New Pricing Imperative
In a SaaS landscape where efficiency metrics are increasingly scrutinized and value capture is paramount, pricing experimentation is transitioning from a neglected discipline to a strategic imperative. The companies that overcome organizational, technical, and cultural barriers to pricing experimentation gain a powerful and sustainable competitive advantage.
By treating pricing as a dynamic, testable element of their business model rather than a static decision, forward-thinking SaaS executives can unlock significant growth without additional customer acquisition costs or product development investments. In an industry obsessed with optimization, pricing may well be the last great under-optimized frontier.