.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, procurement processes are undergoing a significant transformation through AI-driven automation. As organizations deploy multiple AI agents to handle different aspects of procurement, a critical question emerges: what credit model should be used to manage, track, and bill for these automated workflows? This article explores various credit models for multi-agent procurement systems and helps you determine which approach might work best for your organization.
The Rise of Agentic AI in Procurement
Procurement departments are increasingly turning to agentic AI systems—collections of specialized AI agents that work together to handle complex procurement tasks. Unlike traditional automation, these AI agents can negotiate with vendors, compare pricing options, validate compliance requirements, and even make purchasing decisions within defined parameters.
According to a 2023 McKinsey report, organizations that have implemented agentic AI in procurement have seen cost reductions of 15-30% and processing time improvements of up to 85%. However, with this new technology comes the challenge of determining appropriate pricing and credit models.
Understanding Credit Models for AI Systems
Before diving into specific approaches for procurement systems, let's explore the primary credit models used for AI services:
Usage-Based Pricing
Usage-based pricing ties costs directly to consumption metrics. For procurement AI, this might include:
- Number of transactions processed
- Volume of documents analyzed
- Time spent on vendor negotiations
- Number of API calls made to external systems
This model provides transparency and allows organizations to scale costs with actual usage, but can be unpredictable when procurement demands fluctuate seasonally.
Outcome-Based Pricing
Outcome-based pricing links payment to the results achieved by the AI system, such as:
- Percentage of cost savings secured
- Reduction in procurement cycle time
- Improved vendor compliance rates
- Success rate of automated negotiations
While this approach aligns incentives with business goals, it requires sophisticated tracking mechanisms and clear definitions of success metrics.
Credit-Based Pricing
Credit-based pricing involves purchasing a pool of "credits" that are consumed as various AI agents within the procurement workflow perform different tasks. This model offers several advantages:
- Flexibility to allocate resources across different procurement activities
- Ability to assign different credit values to different types of tasks
- Simplified billing and budgeting with prepurchased credit pools
- Potential for volume discounts when purchasing credits in bulk
This approach has gained popularity for multi-agent systems because it provides both predictability for budgeting and flexibility for operations.
Evaluating Credit Models for Multi-Agent Procurement Systems
When multiple AI agents work together in a procurement workflow, the complexity of tracking usage and determining appropriate billing increases significantly. Here's how different credit models function in this context:
Challenge: Varying Resource Consumption
Different procurement tasks require vastly different computational resources. For example, a simple vendor validation might consume minimal resources, while an AI agent negotiating contract terms might require extensive processing power.
Solution with Credit-Based Pricing: Each agent can draw from a shared pool of credits, with more complex tasks consuming more credits. This allows for fair allocation based on the actual value and resource intensity of each task.
Challenge: Orchestration Overhead
Multi-agent systems require robust orchestration—the coordination of different AI agents working together. This orchestration layer adds overhead that must be accounted for in pricing.
Solution with Credit-Based Pricing: Credits can be allocated not just for individual agent actions but also for the orchestration processes that coordinate them, providing a comprehensive view of system costs.
Implementing an Effective Credit Model for Procurement Automation
Based on our research and industry best practices, here's a framework for implementing an effective credit model for multi-agent procurement workflows:
1. Establish Clear Credit Valuations
Define what constitutes one "credit" in your system and how credits are consumed by different types of procurement tasks. For example:
- Simple document verification: 1 credit
- Vendor comparison analysis: 5 credits
- Automated negotiation session: 10 credits
- Contract compliance review: 7 credits
2. Implement Proper Guardrails
Credit systems need appropriate guardrails to prevent unexpected resource consumption. These might include:
- Credit consumption caps for specific agent types
- Approval workflows for high-credit-consuming tasks
- Alerts when credit consumption rates exceed normal patterns
- Option to pause automated processes when credit thresholds are reached
3. Provide Transparent Reporting
Users should have clear visibility into how credits are being consumed across the procurement workflow:
- Real-time dashboards showing credit utilization
- Breakdowns of credit consumption by agent type
- Historical usage patterns to aid in future credit purchases
- ROI metrics comparing credit costs to procurement savings
4. Integrate with LLMOps
For organizations using Large Language Models (LLMs) in their procurement agents, integration with LLMOps (LLM Operations) platforms is crucial:
- Track token usage and computational resources
- Monitor agent performance and efficiency
- Optimize prompts to reduce unnecessary credit consumption
- Implement version control for agent improvements
Case Study: Global Manufacturing Company
A global manufacturing company implemented a credit-based pricing model for their multi-agent procurement system with impressive results. Their system included:
- Vendor verification agents
- Price comparison agents
- Regulatory compliance agents
- Negotiation agents
- Contract management agents
By implementing a unified credit system across these agents, they achieved:
- 22% reduction in procurement costs
- 78% faster processing time
- Improved budget predictability with prepurchased credit pools
- Better allocation of AI resources to high-value procurement activities
The company found that credit-based pricing provided the flexibility needed to handle their diverse procurement needs while maintaining cost control and predictability.
Which Credit Model Is Right for Your Organization?
When deciding on a credit model for your multi-agent procurement system, consider these factors:
Usage-based pricing may be ideal if:
- Your procurement volume is stable and predictable
- You want maximum transparency in costs
- You're in early adoption stages and testing the waters
Outcome-based pricing might work best if:
- You're focused primarily on cost savings as a success metric
- You have sophisticated tracking systems in place
- You want to align vendor incentives with your goals
Credit-based pricing is typically optimal if:
- You have multiple AI agents working across different procurement functions
- Your procurement needs vary significantly month to month
- You want budget predictability with flexibility
- You need fine-grained control over resource allocation
Conclusion
As agentic AI transforms procurement processes, choosing the right credit model becomes a strategic decision that impacts both operational effectiveness and financial outcomes. For most multi-agent procurement systems, a credit-based pricing model offers the ideal balance of flexibility, predictability, and control.
Regardless of which model you choose, ensure that your system includes proper guardrails, transparent reporting, and effective orchestration. With these elements in place, your organization can maximize the value of AI-driven procurement while maintaining appropriate cost controls.
When implemented correctly, the right credit model doesn't just facilitate billing—it becomes a strategic tool for optimizing your entire procurement automation ecosystem.