.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In today's competitive SaaS landscape, choosing the right pricing strategy can make or break your business. Two common approaches—tiered pricing and cost-plus pricing—represent fundamentally different philosophies about how to monetize your product. Understanding these differences is crucial for optimizing revenue, attracting the right customers, and building sustainable growth.
Understanding Tiered Pricing
Tiered pricing is a subscription billing model where customers pay based on predefined service levels or packages. Each tier includes specific features, usage limits, or service levels at different price points.
How Tiered Pricing Works
With tiered pricing, you create distinct packages (often labeled as Basic, Professional, Enterprise, etc.) with progressively more value as customers move up the ladder. Each tier includes a specific set of features or usage limits.
For example, a project management SaaS might offer:
- Basic ($10/month): 5 projects, 3 users, basic features
- Professional ($25/month): 15 projects, 10 users, advanced features
- Enterprise ($50/month): Unlimited projects, 25 users, all features
Advantages of Tiered Pricing
Value-based approach: Tiered pricing aligns with value-based pricing principles, as customers pay based on the value they receive rather than your costs.
Customer segmentation: This model naturally segments your market, allowing you to serve different customer types with appropriate feature sets.
Growth path: As customers' needs expand, they have a clear upgrade path, increasing customer lifetime value over time.
Psychological anchoring: The presence of higher tiers makes mid-level options appear more attractive, often driving customers to select higher-priced options than they might have otherwise.
Challenges with Tiered Pricing
Complexity in design: Creating the right tiers with appropriate feature combinations requires deep market understanding.
Feature differentiation: You must decide which features belong in which tiers—a strategic decision that impacts both adoption and customer satisfaction.
Potential for customer frustration: When desired features span across tiers, customers may feel forced to pay for features they don't need.
Understanding Cost-Plus Pricing
Cost-plus pricing is a straightforward approach where you calculate your costs to deliver the service and add a predetermined markup to ensure profitability.
How Cost-Plus Pricing Works
With cost-plus pricing, you:
- Calculate all costs associated with your product (development, hosting, support, etc.)
- Add a fixed percentage markup (e.g., 30%)
- Set this as your price
For example, if your SaaS costs $70 per user per year to deliver and you want a 30% profit margin, you would price it at $91 per user annually.
Advantages of Cost-Plus Pricing
Simplicity: This model is straightforward to calculate and explain internally.
Guaranteed margins: When implemented correctly, cost-plus ensures profitability for each customer.
Easier financial forecasting: With predictable margins, financial planning becomes more straightforward.
Challenges with Cost-Plus Pricing
Disconnection from value: The biggest drawback is that cost-plus ignores the actual value your solution delivers to customers.
Missed opportunity for premium pricing: Products that solve critical business problems often command prices far above their costs.
Less competitive positioning: In the SaaS world, competitors with value-based pricing may capture more market share with more strategic pricing.
Key Differences Between Tiered and Cost-Plus Pricing
1. Pricing Philosophy
Tiered pricing is customer-focused and based on perceived value and willingness to pay.
Cost-plus pricing is internally focused and based on company expenses and desired margins.
2. Market Sensitivity
Tiered pricing responds to market demands, competitive landscapes, and customer segments.
Cost-plus pricing largely ignores market conditions, focusing instead on internal metrics.
3. Revenue Optimization
Tiered pricing can maximize revenue by capturing different price points across customer segments.
Cost-plus pricing typically leaves money on the table, especially from high-value customers.
4. Scalability
Tiered pricing scales well with SaaS business models, supporting feature-based pricing and usage-based pricing components.
Cost-plus pricing becomes less relevant as a SaaS business scales, since marginal costs decrease while value remains constant or increases.
5. Customer Perception
Tiered pricing communicates value propositions clearly through package differentiation.
Cost-plus pricing offers limited differentiation and may position your product as a commodity.
Which Pricing Model Is Right for Your SaaS Business?
The best pricing model depends on your specific circumstances:
Consider tiered pricing when:
- You serve diverse customer segments with varying needs
- Your product has distinct feature sets that appeal to different users
- You want to reduce churn by providing upgrade paths
- You're looking to maximize customer lifetime value
- You offer a complex product where feature-based pricing makes sense
Consider cost-plus pricing when:
- You operate in a highly commoditized market
- Your costs are substantial and relatively fixed per customer
- You're in early stages and need a simple starting point
- Regulatory or contractual requirements demand transparent pricing
Hybrid Approaches
Many successful SaaS companies employ hybrid pricing strategies. For instance:
- Starting with cost-plus to ensure profitability, then evolving to tiered pricing as you better understand customer segments
- Using tiered pricing as the foundation but ensuring no tier falls below cost-plus minimums
- Implementing freemium or free trial models within a tiered structure to drive acquisition
According to OpenView Partners' 2022 SaaS Benchmark Report, companies that implement sophisticated pricing strategies like tiered models see 30% higher growth rates than those using simpler approaches like cost-plus.
Implementation Tips
If you're considering a switch to tiered pricing:
- Research your customer base to identify natural segmentation points
- Analyze usage patterns to determine appropriate limits for each tier
- Test pricing with focus groups before full rollout
- Create clear product positioning for each tier
- Train your sales team on communicating the value of each tier
- Establish a sales compensation plan that incentivizes appropriate tier placement
- Monitor customer behavior and be prepared to adjust
Conclusion
While cost-plus pricing offers simplicity, tiered pricing aligns better with SaaS business models and customer expectations. By focusing on value rather than costs, tiered pricing enables more strategic packaging, better market segmentation, and ultimately higher revenue potential.
The most successful SaaS companies regularly review their pricing strategies, adapting them as markets evolve and customer needs change. Whether you choose tiered pricing, cost-plus, or a hybrid approach, the key is to ensure your pricing reflects the value you deliver while supporting sustainable growth.