.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
In the competitive landscape of SaaS, your pricing strategy can make or break your business. Yet many executives continue to underestimate its impact, defaulting to cost-plus models that potentially leave millions in revenue uncaptured. This critical decision—whether to base your pricing on your internal costs or your customers' perceived value—deserves strategic consideration.
The Pricing Strategy Dilemma
According to OpenView Partners' 2023 SaaS Benchmarks report, companies that implement value-based pricing show 30% higher revenue growth compared to those using cost-plus approaches. Despite this, approximately 65% of SaaS companies still primarily use cost-plus models.
Why this disconnect? Because cost-plus pricing feels safe. It's straightforward, predictable, and ensures margins. But in the subscription economy where acquisition costs are high and lifetime value is everything, this traditional approach may be holding your growth back.
Understanding Cost-Plus Pricing
Cost-plus pricing follows a simple formula: calculate your costs, add a markup percentage, and there's your price. This model typically includes:
- Product development costs: Engineering hours, infrastructure
- Operating expenses: Support, marketing, sales
- Desired profit margin: Usually 10-30%
Advantages
- Simplicity: Easy to calculate and justify internally
- Predictable margins: Ensures basic profitability
- Clear communication: Straightforward to explain to stakeholders
Limitations
- Ignores market conditions: Doesn't consider what customers will pay
- Undermines differentiation: Your unique value proposition doesn't factor into pricing
- Caps upside potential: Revenue ceiling based on costs rather than value
As Tomasz Tunguz of Redpoint Ventures notes, "Cost-plus pricing is leaving money on the table for most SaaS companies, especially those with strong differentiation."
The Value-Based Alternative
Value-based pricing flips the equation. Instead of starting with your costs, you begin with the economic benefit your solution delivers to customers.
This approach requires:
- Quantifying customer ROI: Measuring the financial impact of your solution
- Market segmentation: Understanding willingness-to-pay across different customer segments
- Feature value mapping: Determining which capabilities drive the most value
Advantages
- Higher revenue potential: Prices reflect value rather than costs
- Better market alignment: Pricing flexes with customer segments
- Strategic positioning: Reinforces your value proposition
Limitations
- Implementation complexity: Requires deeper market research
- Continuous refinement: Needs ongoing validation and adjustment
- Internal resistance: May face pushback from teams accustomed to cost-plus thinking
Real-World Success Stories
Drift: Value-Based Transformation
Conversational marketing platform Drift initially used a simple cost-plus model with three tiers. After switching to value-based pricing, they expanded to five tiers with prices aligned to customer outcomes rather than features alone. According to their former VP of Product, the change drove a 30% increase in average contract value.
HubSpot: Mixed Model Mastery
HubSpot employs a hybrid approach—using value-based principles for their premium tiers while maintaining cost-plus simplicity for entry-level offerings. This strategy has supported their expansion from a $90 million to a $1.6 billion revenue company, with steadily increasing average revenue per customer.
Which Model Is Right for Your SaaS?
Consider these factors when making your decision:
Choose Cost-Plus When:
- You're in a highly commoditized market with little differentiation
- You lack reliable data on customer ROI
- You need a simple starting point before evolving your strategy
Choose Value-Based When:
- Your solution delivers measurable economic benefits
- You serve multiple market segments with different needs
- Your product has strong differentiation from competitors
Making the Transition
If you're currently using cost-plus pricing but recognize the potential of value-based approaches, consider this transitional roadmap:
- Start with research: Gather data on customer outcomes and willingness-to-pay
- Pilot with new customers: Test value-based pricing with new prospects before changing existing accounts
- Segment strategically: Create pricing tiers based on value patterns, not just feature bundles
- Communicate value: Train your sales team to sell on value, not features or costs
As Patrick Campbell, founder of ProfitWell (acquired by Paddle), observes: "The companies that win in SaaS are those that align their pricing with the value they create, not the costs they incur."
Conclusion
While cost-plus pricing offers simplicity and predictability, value-based pricing unlocks the full revenue potential of your SaaS solution. The right approach depends on your market position, growth stage, and competitive landscape.
The most successful SaaS companies today aren't just building valuable products—they're capturing that value through strategic pricing. As you evaluate your current pricing model, consider whether you're truly monetizing the full impact of your solution or merely covering your costs with a modest margin.
In a subscription business where customer lifetime value is paramount, aligning your pricing with the value you deliver isn't just good strategy—it's essential for sustainable growth.