.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
Introduction
In today's competitive SaaS landscape, pricing is far more than a number on a webpage—it's a strategic lever that directly impacts revenue, customer acquisition, and long-term business sustainability. Yet many executives approach pricing with intuition rather than evidence. According to a study by Simon-Kucher & Partners, companies that conduct systematic pricing experiments achieve 3-7% higher profit margins than those who don't. This significant advantage stems from one simple truth: pricing is not a set-it-and-forget-it decision but an ongoing opportunity for optimization.
This guide explores practical strategies for implementing pricing experiments that deliver actionable insights without disrupting your business or alienating customers. Whether you're looking to increase average revenue per user (ARPU), improve conversion rates, or test the market's response to new value metrics, these evidence-based approaches will help you make confident pricing decisions.
Why Pricing Experimentation Matters
Pricing experimentation is the systematic process of testing different pricing strategies to determine what resonates best with customers while maximizing revenue. Unlike many other business decisions, pricing changes have immediate and measurable impacts on key metrics:
A ProfitWell study found that a 1% improvement in pricing optimization can result in an 11.1% increase in profits—larger than the impact of a 1% improvement in customer acquisition costs (3.3%) or retention (6.7%).
According to OpenView Partners' 2022 SaaS Benchmarks report, companies that regularly test pricing increase revenue by 10-15% more annually than those with static pricing strategies.
Despite these compelling statistics, Price Intelligently reports that the average SaaS company spends just 6 hours determining their pricing strategy. This disconnect represents both a challenge and an opportunity for forward-thinking executives.
Setting Up Your Pricing Experiment Framework
Define Clear Objectives
Before running any pricing experiment, establish specific objectives:
- Are you testing price sensitivity?
- Evaluating a new pricing model (e.g., usage-based vs. tiered)?
- Assessing willingness to pay for specific features?
Example objective: "Determine if increasing our Professional tier price by 15% impacts conversion rates from trials while maintaining overall revenue."
Select Your Experimental Approach
Several methodologies exist for pricing experimentation:
1. A/B Testing
Present different pricing to different segments of your audience simultaneously.
Pros: Direct comparison, statistically robust
Cons: Potential customer confusion if discovered
Implementation tip: Use geofencing to test pricing variations in different geographic markets to minimize the risk of price comparison.
2. Sequential Testing
Change pricing for all users and measure results against historical baselines.
Pros: Simpler to implement, avoids customer complaints about different pricing
Cons: Less controlled, susceptible to seasonal variations
Implementation tip: Run tests for complete business cycles (at least 1-3 months) to account for monthly fluctuations.
3. Feature-Based Testing
Test willingness to pay for specific features rather than overall price changes.
Pros: Lower risk, provides granular data on feature value
Cons: May not capture overall price sensitivity
HubSpot successfully employed this method by testing premium features before bundling them into higher-tier packages, increasing their Enterprise tier adoption by 27%.
Measurement Framework
Establish clear metrics to evaluate success:
- Conversion rate changes (trial-to-paid, freemium-to-premium)
- Average revenue per user (ARPU)
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC) relative to lifetime value (LTV)
- Churn rate impacts
- Customer satisfaction scores
Document these metrics before beginning your experiment to ensure objective evaluation.
Practical Pricing Experiment Strategies
Strategy 1: The Grandfather Approach
When testing price increases, "grandfather" existing customers at their current rate while implementing new pricing for new customers.
Example: Slack implemented this strategy when raising prices in 2018, maintaining goodwill with existing customers while gradually shifting their revenue model.
Implementation steps:
- Communicate transparently with existing customers that they're receiving preferred pricing
- Set a timeline for how long grandfathering will last (indefinite or time-limited)
- Measure both retention of existing customers and conversion of new prospects
Strategy 2: Value Metric Experimentation
Test different value metrics (the unit by which you charge) rather than just testing price points.
Example: Intercom shifted from a user-based to a conversation-based pricing model, aligning pricing with customer value perception and increasing average contract values by 32%.
Implementation steps:
- Identify 2-3 potential value metrics aligned with customer value
- Create separate landing pages or offers testing each metric
- Analyze not just conversion rates but long-term satisfaction and expansion revenue
Strategy 3: Segmented Price Testing
Different customer segments have different price sensitivities and value perceptions.
Example: Zendesk implements different pricing for startups, SMBs, and enterprise customers, with customized packaging for each.
Implementation steps:
- Identify clear customer segments (by company size, use case, industry, etc.)
- Develop segment-specific value propositions and pricing
- Test willingness to pay within each segment separately
- Analyze cross-segment insights for broader pricing strategy implications
Strategy 4: Decoy Pricing
Introduce a strategically placed third option to influence purchasing decisions toward your preferred option.
Example: The Economist famously offered digital-only subscriptions for $59, print-only for $125, and print+digital for $125. The middle option served as a "decoy" making the highest-tier option seem like an obvious choice.
Implementation steps:
- Identify your target package/price point
- Create slightly less attractive alternatives that make your preferred option shine
- Test conversion rates between different presentation arrangements
Managing Pricing Experiment Risks
Customer Communication Strategies
Price changes, especially increases, require thoughtful communication:
- Value-first messaging: Focus on the value delivered rather than the price change itself
- Advance notice: Give customers time to adjust to upcoming changes
- Benefit reinforcement: Remind customers of all they receive, not just what they pay
- Improvement roadmap: Connect price changes to upcoming improvements
Legal and Ethical Considerations
Price testing must adhere to legal and ethical standards:
- In many jurisdictions, price discrimination laws may apply to B2C offerings
- Terms of service should clearly state that pricing may vary
- Consider disclosure policies—some companies explicitly mention they test pricing
- Ensure compliance with GDPR and other privacy regulations when segmenting customers
Case Study: How Zoom Optimized Pricing Through Experimentation
In 2019, Zoom implemented a strategic pricing experiment before their famous pandemic-driven growth. They:
- Identified that their differentiation was simplicity and reliability
- Tested higher price points against competitors while maintaining their free tier
- Experimented with participant limits rather than time limits as their key value metric
- Used sequential testing to gradually increase enterprise pricing while holding SMB pricing steady
The result: Zoom increased average contract value by 22% without impacting conversion rates. Their enterprise revenue grew 114% year-over-year, significantly outpacing overall customer growth.
The key insight from their experimentation was that enterprise customers valued reliability and participant capacity far more than price sensitivity would suggest, allowing for premium positioning in that segment.
Implementation Timeline and Resources
A typical pricing experiment follows this timeline:
Weeks 1-2: Preparation
- Define objectives and metrics
- Establish baseline measurements
- Prepare technical implementation
- Draft communication strategy
Weeks 3-6: Active Testing
- Launch experiment
- Monitor early indicators
- Prepare for potential adjustments
Weeks 7-8: Analysis
- Gather full data set
- Analyze results against objectives
- Document learnings
Resources required:
- Analytics capability to segment and measure customer behavior
- Technical resources to implement different pricing presentations
- Customer support training for handling questions
- Executive alignment on experiment parameters and decision criteria
Conclusion: Building a Pricing Experimentation Culture
The most successful SaaS companies don't view pricing experiments as one-off projects but as ongoing business practices. Companies like Stripe, HubSpot, and Salesforce have developed pricing experimentation capabilities as core competencies, with dedicated teams and regular testing cadences.
To build this capability in your organization:
- Start small with controlled experiments that limit downside risk
- Document and share learnings across departments
- Create a pricing council with cross-functional representatives
- Establish a quarterly or bi-annual pricing review process
- Develop institutional knowledge about customer willingness to pay
Remember that pricing is perhaps the most powerful lever available for improving your business economics. A 1% improvement in pricing typically flows directly to your bottom line—making even small optimizations highly valuable.
By implementing the strategies outlined in this guide, you'll develop not just better pricing, but a sustainable competitive