.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
Pricing is perhaps the most powerful growth lever at a SaaS company's disposal. Yet many executives approach pricing changes with trepidation, often clinging to initial pricing structures long after they've ceased to reflect market realities or the evolving value of their product. According to a ProfitWell study, companies that proactively test and optimize their pricing at least quarterly grow 30-40% faster than those that don't. In today's competitive SaaS landscape, strategic pricing experimentation isn't optional—it's essential.
Why Pricing Experiments Matter Now More Than Ever
In an environment where customer acquisition costs continue to rise and investors increasingly demand efficient growth, pricing optimization represents a relatively low-cost path to improved unit economics. Research from OpenView Partners shows that a mere 1% improvement in pricing can yield 11-15% in profit gains—far outstripping the impact of similar improvements in customer acquisition or retention costs.
However, pricing experiments come with risks. Change too much too quickly, and you might trigger customer backlash. Implement tests without proper controls, and your data becomes meaningless. Let's explore the key do's and don'ts that can make the difference between pricing experiments that drive growth and those that cause confusion.
The Do's of SaaS Pricing Experimentation
DO: Establish Clear Hypotheses and Success Metrics
Every pricing experiment should begin with a well-defined hypothesis. For example, "Introducing a higher-tier plan with advanced features will increase our average revenue per user by 15% without negatively impacting conversion rates."
Your hypotheses should be specific, measurable, and tied to business outcomes. According to Price Intelligently, successful pricing teams typically test 3-5 specific hypotheses rather than making sweeping changes across their entire pricing structure.
Success metrics might include:
- Conversion rates
- Average revenue per user (ARPU)
- Customer acquisition costs (CAC)
- Lifetime value (LTV)
- Expansion revenue
- Churn rates
DO: Segment Your Tests Appropriately
Not all customers will respond the same way to pricing changes. Zuora's Subscription Economy Index reveals that companies that segment their pricing tests based on customer personas see 28% higher growth rates than those that don't.
Consider segmenting your experiments by:
- Company size or industry
- Usage patterns
- Geographic regions
- Acquisition channels
- New vs. existing customers
DO: Conduct Proper Customer Research First
Effective pricing isn't just about what you think your product is worth—it's about what customers perceive as valuable. Before implementing experiments, invest in understanding customer willingness to pay (WTP) and feature value perception.
Methods might include:
- Van Westendorp Price Sensitivity Meters
- Gabor-Granger pricing studies
- Conjoint analysis
- Customer interviews focused on value perception
- Feature value ranking exercises
According to research by Simon-Kucher & Partners, companies that conduct regular customer value research achieve profit margins that are 25% higher than those that don't.
DO: Run A/B Tests Whenever Possible
A/B testing allows you to compare the performance of different pricing strategies with statistical validity. Tools like Optimizely or VWO can help implement these tests on your pricing pages.
When running A/B tests:
- Ensure sufficient sample size for statistical significance
- Test one variable at a time when possible
- Run tests long enough to capture full sales cycles
- Account for seasonality and other external factors
The Don'ts of SaaS Pricing Experimentation
DON'T: Make Sweeping Changes Without Testing
According to a study by SaaS Capital, 70% of companies that make major pricing changes without prior testing experience unexpected negative consequences. Avoid the temptation to completely overhaul your pricing structure in one go.
Instead, consider:
- Testing price increases on a small segment first
- Piloting new pricing tiers with beta customers
- Introducing new packaging options alongside existing ones
DON'T: Neglect Existing Customers
While pricing experiments often focus on new customer acquisition, your existing customer base deserves careful consideration. According to Bain & Company, a 5% increase in customer retention can increase profits by 25% to 95%.
When implementing pricing changes:
- Communicate changes clearly and well in advance
- Consider grandfathering existing customers
- Offer transition options or discounts
- Highlight new value being delivered with price increases
DON'T: Focus Solely on Price Points
Pricing experimentation isn't just about changing dollar amounts. In fact, research from Price Intelligently suggests that packaging and positioning adjustments often yield better results than simple price increases.
Consider testing:
- Feature bundling and unbundling
- Seat-based vs. usage-based models
- Annual vs. monthly billing incentives
- Add-ons and expansion opportunities
- Value metric adjustments (what you charge for)
DON'T: Ignore the Competitive Landscape
While you shouldn't base your pricing solely on competitors, ignoring the market context can lead to pricing that's disconnected from customer expectations. According to Gartner, companies that regularly analyze competitor pricing are 36% more likely to achieve their revenue growth targets.
Monitor:
- Competitor pricing pages and changes
- Market expansion or contraction
- New entrants or consolidation
- Changes in customer expectations
DON'T: Rely on Discounting as Your Primary Strategy
While strategic discounting has its place, research from Software Equity Group shows that companies with heavy discount practices typically have 30% lower valuations than those with more disciplined pricing.
Instead of reflexive discounting:
- Test value-based justifications for premium pricing
- Experiment with tiered pricing that captures willingness to pay
- Try feature differentiation rather than price cuts
- Consider term-length incentives rather than direct discounts
Implementing Pricing Experiments: A Practical Framework
For SaaS executives ready to embrace pricing experimentation, consider this four-step framework:
Assess Current Performance: Analyze conversion rates, competitive positioning, and customer feedback on existing pricing.
Research & Hypothesize: Conduct customer research to understand willingness to pay and value perception, then formulate specific hypotheses.
Design & Execute Tests: Implement controlled experiments using segmentation and clear success metrics.
Analyze & Iterate: Collect data, analyze results against hypotheses, and use insights to inform the next round of experimentation.
Conclusion: Building a Pricing Optimization Culture
The most successful SaaS companies view pricing not as a one-time decision but as an ongoing optimization process. According to McKinsey, companies with established pricing functions achieve 7-10% greater profit growth than peers.
By following the do's and don'ts outlined above, you can transform pricing from a source of uncertainty into a strategic advantage. The key is starting small, measuring rigorously, and creating a culture where pricing decisions are driven by data rather than intuition alone.
Remember that the goal isn't to squeeze every possible dollar from customers—it's to align your pricing with the value you deliver, ensuring sustainable growth and customer satisfaction. As the SaaS market continues to mature, those who master the art and science of pricing experimentation will be positioned to thrive, even in challenging economic conditions.