.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
In the highly competitive SaaS landscape, pricing strategy can make or break your conversion rates. While feature differentiation and value communication remain critical, there's a powerful psychological technique that top-performing companies leverage to influence purchase decisions: decoy pricing. This strategic approach to pricing tier design can dramatically increase conversions toward your preferred plans—without manipulating customers or compromising your brand integrity.
The Psychology Behind Decoy Pricing
Decoy pricing (also called the "asymmetric dominance effect") works by introducing a strategically designed third option that makes your target offering appear more attractive. The concept was first documented in a landmark 1982 study by researchers Huber, Payne, and Puto, who found that adding a "decoy" option could shift consumer preference between two original choices.
According to a study by the American Marketing Association, companies implementing well-designed decoy pricing can increase selection of their target plan by up to 40%. The effectiveness stems from how humans make comparative decisions rather than absolute value judgments.
How Decoy Pricing Works in SaaS
In a typical SaaS pricing structure, you might offer:
- A budget plan with limited features
- A premium plan with comprehensive features
- A middle-tier plan (the strategic decoy)
When designed effectively, the decoy makes your premium plan seem like an obvious choice. Here's how to implement this approach:
1. Identify Your Money-Making Plan
Before designing your decoy, clearly determine which pricing tier drives your optimal revenue and profit. For most SaaS companies, this is typically the premium or middle tier.
"Most companies should aim to have 60-70% of customers select their middle tier plan," notes Patrick Campbell, founder of ProfitWell. "That's typically where the value-price equation is most balanced for both parties."
2. Create Asymmetric Value Distribution
The key to an effective decoy is creating what pricing strategists call an "asymmetrically dominated" option. This means designing a plan that is:
- Clearly inferior to your target plan
- Not significantly cheaper than your target plan
- Better than your entry-level plan in some aspects
For example, if your premium plan costs $100/month with unlimited features and your basic plan is $50/month with core features, your decoy might be $85/month with slightly fewer features than premium. The small price difference but notable feature gap makes the premium option feel like a bargain.
3. Leverage Strategic Feature Breakpoints
Careful feature allocation across tiers is critical for decoy pricing success. Adobe Creative Cloud masterfully implements this strategy by placing high-demand features at specific breakpoints that make higher tiers more attractive.
Consider these approaches:
- Pack high-value features in your target plan: Ensure the jump from decoy to target plan delivers disproportionate value
- Create usage thresholds strategically: If your decoy offers 100 units and your target plan offers unlimited, many customers will select the target plan to avoid constraints
- Bundle complementary features: Group features that naturally work together in your target plan, while separating them in the decoy
4. Use Visual Hierarchy to Guide Attention
The presentation of your pricing tiers significantly impacts their effectiveness. According to eye-tracking studies conducted by ConversionXL, customers typically scan pricing pages in an "E" or "F" pattern, with most attention given to the middle or highlighted options.
Implement these design tactics:
- Position your target plan in the middle or slightly right of center
- Use subtle visual cues like badges ("Most Popular"), contrasting colors, or slight size differences
- Keep the vertical alignment of feature comparisons perfectly aligned for easy scanning
Real-World Examples of Effective Decoy Pricing
The Economist's Classic Case
One of the most frequently cited examples comes from The Economist, which once offered:
- Web-only subscription: $59
- Print-only subscription: $125 (the decoy)
- Print + web subscription: $125
When presented with only the web-only and print+web options, 68% chose the web-only option. But when the print-only decoy was introduced at the same price as the print+web bundle, 84% selected the print+web option—a 16 percentage point increase in premium conversions.
Slack's Tier Strategy
Slack's pricing structure demonstrates sophisticated decoy principles:
- Standard plan: $6.67 per user
- Plus plan: $12.50 per user (target tier)
- Enterprise Grid: Custom pricing
The Plus plan offers compliance exports, 99.99% uptime, and SAML—features that many businesses need but aren't included in Standard. The price jump is significant enough that very small teams might choose Standard, but the feature gap is designed to push security-conscious or larger organizations toward Plus.
Testing and Optimizing Your Decoy Strategy
Implementing decoy pricing isn't a set-it-and-forget-it tactic. Continuous optimization is essential:
- A/B test different configurations: Test tier arrangements, feature distributions, and price points with different segments
- Track plan selection rates: Monitor how selection percentages shift after implementing your decoy
- Measure upgrade/downgrade behavior: Evaluate how often customers move between tiers after initial selection
- Collect qualitative feedback: Survey customers about their decision process to refine your approach
According to price optimization platform Price Intelligently, companies that regularly test their pricing tiers see 30% higher revenue growth than those with static pricing structures.
Ethical Considerations in Decoy Pricing
While decoy pricing leverages psychological principles, it shouldn't be deceptive. The most sustainable implementations focus on highlighting genuine value differences rather than creating artificial constraints.
"The best pricing strategies help customers find the right plan for their needs, not trick them into overpaying," says Lincoln Murphy, customer success strategist. "Your goal should be to optimize for customer lifetime value, not just initial conversion."
Conclusion: Balancing Psychology and Value
Effective decoy pricing is both art and science—blending psychological insights with genuine value differentiation. When implemented ethically, it helps customers make confident decisions while maximizing your revenue potential.
The most successful SaaS companies recognize that their pricing tiers tell a story about their product's value. By strategically designing your decoy options, you can guide prospects toward the plans that deliver appropriate value to them while supporting your business objectives.
Remember that pricing is never static. As your product evolves and market conditions change, continuously test and refine your tier structure to maintain its effectiveness in driving conversions to your target plans.