.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In the competitive SaaS landscape, deciding how to structure your agreement with marketing consultants can significantly impact both your budget and results. The two predominant models—recurring retainer and performance-based pricing—each offer distinct advantages and challenges. For SaaS executives weighing these options, understanding which approach aligns best with your growth objectives and operational style is crucial to maximizing your marketing investment.
The Traditional Retainer Model: Predictability vs. Risk
Retainer pricing, the most common consultancy subscription model, involves paying a fixed monthly fee for an agreed-upon scope of marketing services. According to a 2023 Agency Management Institute survey, approximately 68% of marketing consultants prefer this model.
Key Benefits of Retainer Agreements:
- Predictable budgeting: Fixed recurring marketing fees make financial planning straightforward
- Consistent service level: Guaranteed attention to your account regardless of immediate results
- Relationship building: Long-term partnerships foster deeper understanding of your SaaS product and market
- Comprehensive approach: Allows for strategic marketing that builds momentum over time
For SaaS companies with longer sales cycles and complex buyer journeys, this predictability can be invaluable. Retainers provide cushion for the marketing consultant to execute strategies that might take 3-6 months to demonstrate measurable ROI.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Upfront commitment: You're paying regardless of immediate performance
- Potentially misaligned incentives: Without direct ties to results, some consultants might not maximize effort
- Scope creep: Without clear boundaries, extra fees may arise for work beyond the original agreement
As Rand Fishkin, founder of SparkToro, notes: "Retainers work best when both parties have clear expectations about what success looks like, even when it's not directly tied to revenue."
Performance-Based Pricing: Results-Driven but Complex
Performance-based marketing consultant pricing links compensation directly to predefined KPIs—whether that's lead generation, MQLs, conversion rates, or revenue growth.
Key Benefits of Performance Pricing:
- Aligned incentives: The consultant only succeeds when you succeed
- Lower initial risk: Often involves smaller base fees with performance bonuses
- Focus on measurable outcomes: Naturally prioritizes tactics with clear ROI
- Scalability: Payments grow proportionally with success
According to a HubSpot study, SaaS companies using performance-based consultant agreements reported 22% higher satisfaction with their ROI compared to those using pure retainer models.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Attribution challenges: Determining which activities directly led to results can be problematic
- Short-term focus: May incentivize quick wins over sustainable growth strategies
- Higher costs with success: Top performance could mean significantly higher fees than a retainer
- Complexity: Agreements typically require sophisticated tracking and agreement on metrics
"Performance-based compensation works when you can clearly define and measure success," says April Dunford, positioning consultant and author. "But it fails spectacularly when those definitions are ambiguous."
The Hybrid Approach: Best of Both Worlds?
Many SaaS companies are finding success with hybrid models that combine elements of both pricing structures:
- Base retainer + performance bonuses: A moderate monthly fee with additional compensation for exceeding targets
- Scaled retainers: Monthly fees that increase or decrease based on performance tiers
- Initial retainer transitioning to performance: Starting with a retainer during strategy development, then shifting to performance-based once campaigns are established
Neil Patel, co-founder of NP Digital, advocates this approach: "We typically start clients on a retainer to build fundamentals, then transition to include performance elements once we've established baselines and momentum."
How to Choose the Right Model for Your SaaS Company
When evaluating marketing consultant pricing options, consider:
1. Your Growth Stage
- Early-stage: Retainer models often work better when establishing market position
- Growth-stage: Hybrid models balance strategic needs with performance incentives
- Mature: Performance models can help optimize established marketing channels
2. Marketing Objectives
- Brand building: Difficult to measure immediately—retainers make more sense
- Lead generation: Easier to track and attribute—performance-based could work well
- Complex sales funnels: Consider how marketing touchpoints affect long sales cycles
3. Budget Considerations
- Cash flow constraints: Performance models reduce upfront costs
- Budget predictability needs: Retainers provide consistent monthly expenses
- Risk tolerance: How comfortable are you with variable marketing expenses?
Implementation Best Practices
Regardless of which pricing model you select:
- Establish clear metrics: Define KPIs that both parties agree represent success
- Document everything: Comprehensive agreements prevent misunderstandings
- Set realistic timeframes: Allow adequate time for strategies to demonstrate results
- Build in review periods: Quarterly evaluations help keep both parties aligned
- Start with smaller engagements: Test relationship compatibility before major commitments
Conclusion
The choice between recurring retainer and performance-based pricing isn't simply about cost structure—it's about aligning your marketing investment with your business objectives and operational style. Many SaaS companies find that their needs evolve over time, starting with retainer models during relationship building phases and incorporating more performance elements as marketing channels mature.
The most successful consultant relationships, regardless of pricing model, share common characteristics: clear communication, mutual respect, transparent reporting, and shared understanding of what success looks like. By focusing on these fundamentals while selecting the pricing structure that best fits your current needs, you can maximize the value your marketing consultants deliver.