.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
When Free Isn't Working: A Tale of Pricing Transformation
For many SaaS companies, the freemium model represents the golden ticket to rapid user acquisition and sustainable growth. Yet beneath the allure of exponential user signups lies a sobering reality many executives discover too late: free users don't automatically convert to paying customers, and growth without revenue is simply unsustainable.
This case study examines how one mid-market SaaS company, ProjectPro (name changed for confidentiality), transformed their failing freemium model into a profitable pricing strategy that not only salvaged their business but positioned them for long-term success.
The Initial Freemium Failure
In 2019, ProjectPro launched as a project management solution targeting small to medium-sized marketing agencies. Following the conventional wisdom that dominated SaaS at the time, they implemented a classic freemium model:
- Free tier: Basic project tracking for up to 3 projects and 5 users
- Pro tier: $12/user/month for unlimited projects and advanced features
- Enterprise tier: $24/user/month with dedicated support and admin controls
Within 18 months, ProjectPro had accumulated an impressive 45,000 free users. However, their conversion metrics told a troubling story:
- Free-to-paid conversion rate: 1.2% (well below the industry average of 2-5%)
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC): $275
- Average revenue per user (ARPU): $16/month
- Churn rate: 8% monthly
- Runway remaining: 7 months
According to CEO Sarah Miller, "We were drowning in success. Our user growth charts looked fantastic in pitch decks, but our bank account was telling a completely different story."
Diagnosing the Problem
The company brought in pricing consultant David Chen, who identified several critical issues:
Value misalignment: Their free tier included most features users actually needed, creating what Chen calls a "value ceiling" that discouraged upgrades.
Wrong customer segment: Data revealed that while small agencies (1-5 employees) dominated their free tier, their paying customers predominantly came from mid-sized agencies (10-50 employees) with different needs.
Cost structure imbalance: Free users consumed approximately 82% of infrastructure costs while generating 0% of revenue.
Weak differentiation: The gap between free and paid tiers wasn't compelling enough to drive conversions.
The Pricing Transformation Strategy
ProjectPro implemented a four-phase approach to transform their pricing:
Phase 1: Value Research & Segmentation
Rather than guessing what users valued, ProjectPro conducted deep research:
- Feature usage analysis across 45,000 free users
- Interviews with both converting and non-converting customers
- Competitive pricing analysis across 12 competitors
- Willingness-to-pay surveys segmented by company size
This research revealed a surprising insight: their most successful conversions came from mid-sized agencies using ProjectPro specifically for client billing and time tracking – features they had considered secondary.
Phase 2: Value-Based Realignment
ProjectPro completely reconstructed their tiers around value metrics that mattered:
- Free tier: Limited to 2 projects, basic functionality, and no client billing features
- Starter tier: $19/user/month for 10 projects and basic client billing
- Growth tier: $39/user/month for unlimited projects and advanced client reporting
- Scale tier: $59/user/month with white-labeling and client portal access
The most significant change was moving their most valuable feature – client billing – behind the paywall while creating a clearer upgrade path tied to business outcomes.
Phase 3: Migration & Communication
The transition required thoughtful change management:
- Existing free users were grandfathered for 60 days
- Educational webinars explained the value of new tiers
- One-time discounts offered for annual commitments
- Clear migration paths provided for each user segment
As CFO Michael Torres noted, "We expected backlash, but by focusing our communication on value rather than features, we managed to convert many free users who suddenly understood why our solution was worth paying for."
Phase 4: Optimization & Testing
After implementing the new structure, ProjectPro continued refining:
- A/B testing different price points for new users
- Adding usage limits rather than feature limits on certain functions
- Experimenting with different trial periods (7, 14, and 30 days)
- Testing add-on packages for specialized use cases
Results: The Turnaround
Within 6 months of implementing the new pricing strategy, ProjectPro experienced dramatic improvements:
- Free-to-paid conversion rate: Increased to 4.8%
- Average revenue per user (ARPU): Jumped to $41/month
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC): Reduced to $210
- Monthly churn: Decreased to 4.2%
- Annual recurring revenue: Increased by 217%
Perhaps most telling was the change in their customer base. While their total user count decreased to 32,000 (as some free users departed), their paying customer count grew from 540 to 1,536.
Key Learnings
ProjectPro's experience offers valuable insights for any SaaS company struggling with freemium models:
Freemium isn't for everyone: The model works best when marginal costs are low, network effects are strong, and there's a clear upgrade path.
Value-metric alignment is critical: Pricing should align with how customers measure value and success in their business.
Segmentation drives strategy: Different customer segments have dramatically different willingness to pay and feature needs.
Pricing is a process, not an event: Continuous testing and optimization delivered ongoing improvements to ProjectPro's metrics.
Communicate value, not features: The most successful aspect of ProjectPro's transition was helping users understand the business outcomes they were purchasing, not just features.
Moving Forward: The Right Freemium Approach
ProjectPro didn't abandon freemium entirely – they evolved it. Their current approach uses the free tier strategically as a qualified lead generation tool rather than as the foundation of their growth strategy.
"Free users are still valuable to us," explains Miller, "but now we understand exactly how and why. They're potential customers we're investing in, not a vanity metric for investor decks."
For SaaS executives facing similar challenges, ProjectPro's journey demonstrates that pricing strategy isn't just about revenue – it's about creating alignment between your business model and the value you deliver to customers. When those elements come together, both the company and its customers win.
As your company evaluates its own pricing strategy, consider whether your current model truly reflects the value you provide and supports sustainable growth. The answer might be the difference between struggling with impressive user counts and thriving with a robust business model.