.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Introduction: The Critical Nature of Pricing in SaaS
In the competitive SaaS landscape, your pricing strategy can make or break your business. While product features and marketing efforts often take center stage, pricing remains the most powerful lever for improving revenue and profitability. According to a study by Price Intelligently, a mere 1% improvement in pricing strategy can yield an 11% increase in profits—far outpacing the impact of similar improvements in acquisition or retention.
Yet despite this outsized impact, many SaaS executives approach pricing decisions with surprising informality, relying on competitor benchmarks or intuition rather than data. This is where A/B testing for SaaS pricing models becomes invaluable—providing concrete evidence for what pricing structures, plans, and presentation methods actually drive conversions and revenue.
What is A/B Testing for SaaS Pricing?
A/B testing (sometimes called split testing) is a methodical experiment where two or more variants of a pricing page, model, or structure are shown to users at random to determine which performs better against specific business metrics. In the context of subscription pricing, these experiments help companies discover the optimal way to package and present their value proposition.
Unlike product feature testing, pricing experiments directly impact revenue and require particular care in implementation and analysis. Done correctly, they provide clear, statistically significant data to inform your pricing strategy.
Key Metrics to Track in Pricing Experiments
Before launching any pricing test, it's essential to identify the specific metrics that will determine success:
- Conversion rate: The percentage of visitors who become paying customers
- Average revenue per user (ARPU): How much revenue each customer generates
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC): The resources required to acquire each customer
- Lifetime value (LTV): The total revenue expected from a customer over their relationship with your company
- Plan distribution: Which pricing tiers customers select
- Upgrade/downgrade rates: How frequently customers move between pricing tiers
While conversion optimization is often the first focus, remember that higher conversion rates at lower price points might actually decrease overall revenue. Successful SaaS metrics tracking looks at the complete picture.
Types of A/B Tests for SaaS Pricing
1. Price Point Testing
The most straightforward approach tests different price points for the same features. For example, charging $29 vs. $39 per month for your base plan. While simple in concept, this requires careful implementation to avoid confusing or alienating existing customers.
2. Pricing Model Testing
This examines fundamentally different approaches to how you charge:
- Per-user pricing vs. flat-rate
- Usage-based vs. feature-based tiers
- Annual vs. monthly billing options
Intercom famously shifted from a pure per-user model to a combined approach after discovering that their per-user pricing was actively discouraging customer growth.
3. Value Metric Testing
What unit determines how customers pay as they scale? Testing different value metrics can reveal which most closely aligns with customer-perceived value:
- Number of users
- Amount of usage (API calls, storage, etc.)
- Features accessed
- Outcomes achieved
According to research by ProfitWell, companies with value metrics aligned to customer value show 30% higher growth rates and stronger retention than those without.
4. Packaging and Plan Structure Testing
This involves testing how features are distributed across pricing tiers:
- How many plans to offer (two, three, or more?)
- Which features belong in which tiers
- Presenting add-ons vs. all-inclusive packages
Slack's pricing page evolution demonstrates this approach, as they've continually refined which features belong in which tiers based on customer utilization patterns.
5. Pricing Page Presentation
Sometimes the price itself isn't the issue, but rather how it's presented:
- Order of plans (placing the preferred plan in the middle)
- Visual emphasis and highlighting
- Feature comparison display methods
- Trial offers vs. freemium models
HubSpot's tests showed that emphasizing annual plans with monthly prices shown (but struck through) increased annual subscription selection by 15%.
Implementing Successful Pricing Experiments
Establish Clear Hypotheses
Every test should start with a clear, testable hypothesis based on customer research, competitor analysis, or previous test results. For example: "Presenting annual pricing with a visible discount percentage will increase annual plan selection rates by at least 10%."
Segment Appropriately
Not all customers respond to pricing changes in the same way. Segment your tests by:
- New vs. existing customers
- Geographic regions (critical for international businesses)
- Customer size or industry
- Acquisition channel
Calculate Required Sample Size
Statistical significance matters greatly in pricing tests. Use a calculator to determine how many visitors you'll need before drawing conclusions. For most SaaS businesses, this means running tests for several weeks to achieve reliable results.
Consider Ethical and Legal Implications
Price testing raises several ethical considerations:
- Transparency with customers
- Potential backlash if wildly different prices are discovered
- Legal requirements in some jurisdictions regarding price discrimination
Many companies address this by testing only with new visitors or by offering the better deal to all customers once the test concludes.
Case Study: How Optimizely Optimized Their Own Pricing
Optimizely, a leader in experimentation platforms, applied their own technology to test their pricing models. They had hypothesized that their complex pricing table with numerous features was overwhelming potential customers.
Through A/B testing, they tested a simplified three-tier structure against their original model. The results were striking: the simplified version increased demo requests by 30% and self-service conversions by 20%.
What made this test particularly effective was their focus not just on short-term conversion metrics but on customer quality. They tracked how customers acquired through each variant performed over time, finding that the simplified model not only converted better but also led to higher customer lifetime values.
Common Pitfalls in SaaS Pricing Tests
1. Testing Too Many Variables Simultaneously
When you change multiple pricing elements at once, you can't determine which specific change drove results. Isolate variables where possible.
2. Running Tests for Insufficient Durations
Pricing decisions often have longer consideration cycles than other conversion optimizations. Tests often need to run for 3-4 weeks to capture the full customer decision process.
3. Ignoring Seasonality
B2B SaaS companies often see purchase pattern variations around fiscal quarters and year-end. Ensure your testing periods account for these fluctuations.
4. Overlooking Customer Segments
A pricing change that works well for enterprise customers might backfire with small businesses. Always segment your results.
5. Focusing Only on Conversion Rates
The goal isn't just more customers; it's more revenue. A lower price point might boost conversions while reducing overall revenue and profitability.
Implementing Changes After Testing
Once you've identified winning pricing structures through revenue testing, implementation requires careful planning:
- For new customers: Implement changes immediately
- For existing customers: Consider grandfathering them at current rates or providing advance notice and clear communication
- For future testing: Document learnings to inform the next round of experiments
Conclusion: Continuous Optimization of Pricing Strategy
A/B testing for SaaS pricing isn't a one-time activity but an ongoing process of refinement. The most successful SaaS companies typically revisit their pricing strategy quarterly and run continuous experiments to optimize revenue.
According to OpenView Partners' SaaS Benchmarks Report, companies that regularly test and optimize pricing grow 25% faster than those that set pricing once and rarely revisit it. This difference compounds dramatically over time, making pricing optimization one of the highest-leverage activities for SaaS leadership teams.
By approaching pricing with the same data-driven rigor you apply to product development and marketing, you can uncover powerful insights that drive growth and create pricing models that better align with the value you deliver to customers.
As you implement your own subscription pricing experiments, remember that the goal isn't just to extract more revenue, but to create pricing structures that fairly reflect the value you provide—ensuring both business sustainability and customer satisfaction.