How to Identify and Respond to Indirect Competition: Navigating Non-Traditional Pricing Threats

August 28, 2025

Get Started with Pricing Strategy Consulting

Join companies like Zoom, DocuSign, and Twilio using our systematic pricing approach to increase revenue by 12-40% year-over-year.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
How to Identify and Respond to Indirect Competition: Navigating Non-Traditional Pricing Threats

In today's complex business landscape, understanding your competition extends far beyond monitoring direct rivals offering similar products or services. Increasingly, SaaS executives are discovering that their most significant threats come from unexpected places—alternative solutions that customers might choose instead of their offerings. This phenomenon, known as indirect competition, can silently erode your market share while you're focused elsewhere.

What is Indirect Competition and Why Does It Matter?

Indirect competition occurs when businesses offer different products or services that fulfill the same customer need or solve the same problem through alternative approaches. Unlike direct competitors who mirror your business model, indirect competitors may operate in entirely different industries or utilize completely different technologies.

For SaaS companies, indirect competition might include:

  • DIY solutions customers create internally
  • Analog or manual processes that replace software needs
  • Adjacent technologies that expand to cover your feature set
  • Open-source alternatives to paid solutions
  • Emerging platforms that solve problems in novel ways

According to a 2023 Gartner study, 64% of B2B buyers consider alternative solution categories before making purchasing decisions—a 27% increase from just five years ago. This shift demonstrates why identifying non-traditional threats has become crucial for business survival.

How Non-Traditional Threats Undermine Your Pricing Strategy

Non-traditional competitors often disrupt established markets through fundamentally different pricing approaches:

The Zero-Price Alternative

Perhaps the most challenging indirect competitor is the "free" option. Whether it's open-source software, freemium models, or companies offering your core functionality as a minor feature within their broader platform, zero-price alternatives create psychological barriers to your premium pricing.

Research by the Harvard Business Review found that introducing a free alternative to a market can reduce willingness to pay for premium solutions by up to 40%, even when the paid option offers demonstrably superior value.

Bundled Value Propositions

Enterprise software companies increasingly find themselves competing against platforms that bundle similar capabilities as add-ons. Microsoft, Google, and other tech giants frequently incorporate features as "free additions" to their core products that smaller SaaS providers charge for as standalone solutions.

Salesforce exemplifies this strategy by continually expanding its platform functionality, transforming what were once distinct software categories into features within their ecosystem.

Category-Redefining Approaches

Some indirect competitors don't just offer alternative solutions—they reframe the entire problem, making your offering seem obsolete rather than simply inferior.

When Slack entered the market, it didn't position itself as "better email" but as a fundamentally different way to communicate. This approach made traditional communication tools appear outdated, regardless of their actual utility.

Conducting Effective Indirect Competition Analysis

To identify and respond to non-traditional pricing threats, follow this systematic approach:

1. Map the Customer Problem Space, Not Just the Solution Space

Rather than narrowly defining your market by product type, examine all the ways customers might solve their underlying problems:

  • Identify the core job-to-be-done your solution addresses
  • Research all methods (technological, manual, outsourced) that accomplish the same outcome
  • Look for emerging trends in adjacent industries that might converge with yours

"Companies that define competition based on product similarity rather than problem-solving similarity miss 70% of their competitive threats," notes Clayton Christensen of Harvard Business School.

2. Analyze Value Perception Across Alternatives

Understanding how customers perceive value across different solution categories requires looking beyond feature comparisons:

  • Conduct customer interviews specifically asking about alternative approaches they've considered
  • Analyze the total cost of ownership across different solution types
  • Map the complete customer journey to identify where alternative solutions might create better experiences

3. Track Non-Traditional Competitive Signals

Monitoring indirect competition requires different signals than tracking direct competitors:

  • Follow funding in adjacent technology categories
  • Monitor how large platforms are expanding their feature sets
  • Analyze customer support tickets that mention workarounds or alternative approaches
  • Track adoption of open-source or DIY solutions in your target market

Responding to Non-Traditional Pricing Threats

Once you've identified your indirect competition, consider these strategic responses:

Reframe Your Value Proposition

Instead of competing on features or even direct benefits, elevate your messaging to focus on outcomes that alternative solutions cannot match:

  • Emphasize the opportunity costs of choosing alternatives
  • Quantify the total value delivered beyond the core functionality
  • Highlight integration benefits that standalone or DIY options can't match

Consider Structural Pricing Changes

Traditional pricing models may be ineffective against non-traditional competitors:

  • Explore outcome-based pricing that aligns with customer value creation
  • Develop modular pricing structures that allow customers to pay only for what they need
  • Create entry-level offerings that compete with free alternatives while providing clear upgrade paths

Zoom successfully employed this strategy by offering a genuinely useful free tier that outperformed many competitors' paid offerings, creating a natural pathway to paid plans as users' needs grew.

Create Competitive Bundles

Consider strategic partnerships or expanded offerings that counter bundled alternatives:

  • Partner with complementary solutions to create integrated offerings
  • Develop ecosystem advantages through robust integration capabilities
  • Add strategic features specifically designed to neutralize the appeal of alternatives

Educate the Market on Hidden Costs

Many alternative solutions appear less expensive on the surface but carry hidden costs:

  • Develop ROI calculators that account for implementation, maintenance, and opportunity costs
  • Create case studies highlighting customers who switched from alternatives
  • Produce educational content about the total cost of ownership across different solution types

The Future of Competition: Blurring Boundaries

The distinction between direct and indirect competition continues to blur as technology evolves. Today's indirect competitor may be tomorrow's direct rival—or acquisition target. This fluid competitive landscape requires continuous monitoring and strategic flexibility.

According to McKinsey, companies that systematically track and respond to indirect competition achieve 23% higher growth rates than those focused primarily on traditional competitors.

For SaaS executives, the imperative is clear: expand your competitive analysis beyond traditional boundaries. The most significant threat to your business likely isn't the competitor you're watching—it's the alternative solution you haven't noticed yet.

By developing robust processes to identify, monitor, and respond to indirect competition and non-traditional pricing threats, you position your company to defend against market disruption and potentially become the disruptor yourself.

Get Started with Pricing Strategy Consulting

Join companies like Zoom, DocuSign, and Twilio using our systematic pricing approach to increase revenue by 12-40% year-over-year.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.