.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In the complex world of SaaS, pricing isn't just about setting a number—it's about creating a strategic framework that resonates with different customer groups while maximizing your revenue potential. But what happens when your market segments aren't clearly defined? Many SaaS leaders face this common challenge: understanding who their customers really are and how to effectively price for different segments when the boundaries between them seem blurry.
The Challenge of Unclear Market Segmentation in SaaS
Traditional SaaS pricing strategy relies heavily on clearly defined market segments. You might typically divide customers based on company size, industry, use case, or willingness to pay. However, in rapidly evolving markets or innovative product categories, these segments often overlap or remain undefined.
According to a study by Price Intelligently, companies that implement effective pricing segmentation see a 30% higher growth rate compared to those with one-size-fits-all pricing models. Yet, many struggle with implementation when market segments appear ambiguous.
Why Traditional Segmentation Approaches May Fail
When developing your SaaS pricing strategy, conventional wisdom suggests building specific offerings for distinct customer groups. But what if:
- Your product serves multiple use cases across different industries
- Your users have varying value perceptions not clearly correlated with company size
- You're creating a new category without established segmentation patterns
- Your competitor pricing doesn't provide clear benchmarks because they face similar challenges
These scenarios create a "segmentation fog" that makes traditional pricing approaches ineffective. Rather than forcing artificial segments, you need alternative approaches.
Value-Based Segmentation: The Alternative Approach
Instead of segmenting by who customers are, consider segmenting by what they value. Value-based segmentation focuses on the outcomes your customers seek and how much they're willing to pay for those specific outcomes.
Research from OpenView Partners reveals that companies implementing value-based pricing achieve 25% higher revenue growth compared to those using cost-plus or competitor-based models.
How to Implement Value-Based Segmentation:
Identify Value Metrics: Determine what measurable aspects of your product create value for customers, regardless of their industry or size.
Create Value-Based Tiers: Structure pricing around increasing levels of value rather than customer characteristics.
Offer Feature-Based Optionality: Allow customers to self-select based on the features they value most.
Use Scaling Factors: Implement scaling variables (like number of users or usage volume) that naturally align with value creation.
Usage-Based Segmentation When Demographics Fail
When customer demographics don't provide clear segmentation, usage patterns often reveal natural division points. Usage-based pricing has grown significantly, with OpenView's 2023 SaaS Benchmarks Report indicating that 45% of SaaS companies now incorporate some form of usage-based pricing—up from 34% in 2020.
Usage-based segmentation works by:
- Tracking how different customers interact with your product
- Identifying natural breakpoints in usage patterns
- Creating pricing tiers that match these natural usage clusters
- Charging based on metrics that scale with customer value
Cloud infrastructure provider DigitalOcean successfully implemented this approach when their customer base defied traditional segmentation. By focusing on resource consumption patterns rather than customer size or industry, they created a pricing model that appeals to developers across multiple segments.
Behavioral Segmentation for Unclear Markets
Customer behaviors often reveal valuable segmentation opportunities when traditional demographics don't. According to Profitwell, companies using behavioral data for pricing decisions show 13% better retention rates than those relying solely on market research.
Effective behavioral segmentation considers:
- Feature adoption patterns
- User engagement metrics
- Time-to-value measurements
- Purchase decision factors
For example, Slack discovered that while their customers spanned numerous industries and company sizes, their usage patterns formed natural segments based on communication intensity and integration needs. This insight led to their pricing structure that scales with both team size and feature requirements.
Experimental Pricing: Testing When Segments Are Unclear
When market segments remain ambiguous, experimental approaches can help reveal natural divisions:
A/B Testing Different Price Points: Test various price points with similar customer groups to identify price sensitivity clusters.
Feature Packaging Experiments: Offer different feature bundles to discover which combinations resonate with different user types.
Freemium Boundary Testing: Adjust what features sit behind the paywall to identify value thresholds.
Add-On Experimentation: Test optional add-ons to reveal segment-specific willingness to pay for certain capabilities.
AI-Powered Pricing: The New Frontier in SaaS Pricing Segmentation
AI pricing tools are transforming how companies approach segmentation in unclear markets. These tools analyze vast amounts of customer data to identify patterns human analysts might miss.
According to Gartner, by 2025, 75% of B2B software companies will implement AI-driven pricing strategies, up from less than 30% in 2022.
Modern AI pricing platforms can:
- Analyze customer behavior across thousands of data points
- Identify micro-segments based on usage patterns and value perception
- Recommend optimal pricing thresholds for different customer groups
- Continuously adapt as markets evolve
Companies like Zuora and ProfitWell now offer AI-powered pricing tools that help SaaS companies implement dynamic segmentation strategies even when traditional market boundaries are blurry.
How to Proceed When Segments Remain Unclear
If your market segments continue to resist clear definition:
Start with Simplified Tiers: Begin with broadly defined tiers based on the most evident value dimensions.
Implement Progressive Refinement: Plan for regular pricing reviews (quarterly or biannually) to incorporate new segmentation insights.
Employ Customer Development Interviews: Conduct in-depth interviews focusing specifically on value perception and willingness to pay.
Monitor Competitive Positioning: Track how competitors adjust their pricing segmentation as the market matures.
Consider Custom Pricing: For enterprise segments, custom pricing can bridge the gap while you refine your segmentation approach.
Case Study: How Notion Navigated Unclear Segmentation
Notion faced a significant challenge with market segmentation. Their product appealed to individual users, small teams, and enterprise customers with vastly different use cases from knowledge management to project tracking.
Rather than force artificial segments, Notion implemented a value-based approach with:
- A generous free tier for individuals
- Team pricing that scales with user count
- Enterprise pricing with additional security and administration features
- Add-on capabilities for specific use cases
This flexible approach allowed customers to self-segment based on their needs while Notion gathered data to refine their understanding of their market. As patterns emerged, they adjusted their pricing strategy accordingly, resulting in rapid growth across multiple customer segments.
Conclusion: Embracing Segmentation as a Journey
When market segments seem unclear, remember that segmentation isn't a one-time exercise but an evolutionary process. The most successful SaaS companies view pricing segmentation as an ongoing discovery journey rather than a fixed structure.
Start with your best hypothesis, implement flexible pricing mechanisms that allow for refinement, and continuously gather data to improve your segmentation model. Over time, natural segments will emerge, allowing you to optimize your pricing strategy accordingly.
By focusing on value metrics, usage patterns, and behavioral indicators—and potentially leveraging AI pricing tools—you can create effective pricing segmentation even when traditional market boundaries remain blurry. This approach not only maximizes your revenue potential but also creates pricing structures that truly reflect the value your customers receive.