.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In the competitive landscape of SaaS, the temptation to simply match or slightly undercut competitor pricing is strong. After all, it seems like a safe bet—if it works for them, why not for you? But this competitor-based pricing approach often leads to a dangerous race to the bottom, commoditization, and missed revenue opportunities.
According to OpenView Partners' 2023 SaaS Benchmarks Report, companies that develop value-based pricing strategies outperform their market-following counterparts by 30% in annual recurring revenue growth. This stark difference raises an important question: why do so many SaaS executives still default to competitor-based pricing?
The Problem with Competitor-Based SaaS Pricing
When you base your pricing primarily on what competitors charge, you're essentially making several critical assumptions:
Your competitors know what they're doing: Many SaaS companies haven't scientifically optimized their pricing strategy. Following their lead means potentially replicating their mistakes.
Your product delivers identical value: Unless you've built an exact clone, your solution likely solves problems differently or for different customer segments—meaning its value proposition is unique.
Your costs and growth strategy align with theirs: Your infrastructure costs, team composition, and funding situation may be dramatically different from competitors.
Deloitte's Technology Pricing Survey found that 85% of SaaS companies that relied primarily on competitor benchmarks for pricing decisions reported being "somewhat" or "very" dissatisfied with their pricing strategy's effectiveness.
Why Value-Based Pricing Makes More Sense for SaaS
Value-based pricing aligns what customers pay with the specific value they receive. This approach offers several advantages:
1. Higher Margins and Revenue Potential
When pricing reflects the actual value delivered to customers rather than arbitrary market positions, you can capture more of the value you create. Research from Price Intelligently shows that a mere 1% improvement in pricing strategy can yield an 11% increase in profits—far more impact than a similar improvement in acquisition or retention.
2. Stronger Product-Market Alignment
Value-based pricing requires deep customer understanding—what problems they're solving, what outcomes they value, and what alternatives they consider. This insight feeds back into product development, creating a virtuous cycle of better product-market fit.
3. More Sustainable Competitive Position
Companies with value-based pricing are 23% less likely to be impacted by competitive price movements, according to a Boston Consulting Group analysis. When customers understand and appreciate your unique value, price becomes less of a deciding factor.
How to Develop a Value-Based SaaS Pricing Strategy
Making the shift from competitor-based to value-based pricing isn't a simple overnight change. Here's a systematic approach:
Step 1: Understand Your Value Metrics
Identify what specific outcomes your customers achieve using your product. For example:
- Does your solution save time? How much?
- Does it increase revenue? By what percentage?
- Does it reduce costs? To what extent?
- Does it mitigate risks? What would those risks cost?
Salesforce found that customers achieve an average ROI of 299% over three years using their CRM platform. This kind of quantified value becomes a powerful basis for pricing conversations.
Step 2: Segment Your Market Based on Value Perception
Different customer segments will value your solution differently. Segment your market based on:
- Company size and resources
- Industry-specific needs
- Sophistication level
- Growth stage
- Geographic location
HubSpot effectively segments their market with tiered pricing for startups, growing businesses, and enterprises—each tier reflecting the different value perceptions and needs of these segments.
Step 3: Develop a Pricing Structure That Scales With Value
Your pricing structure should align with how customers derive value from your product:
- Per-user pricing: If value increases with each additional user
- Tiered feature-based pricing: If certain features deliver substantially more value
- Usage-based pricing: If value correlates with consumption
- Outcomes-based pricing: Directly tied to measurable customer results
Twilio's usage-based API pricing scales precisely with the value customers receive—the more messages sent or calls made, the more value is delivered.
Step 4: Test and Refine Through Experimentation
Pricing is never "set it and forget it." Implement a continuous improvement cycle:
- Form hypotheses about pricing changes
- Test with controlled customer segments
- Measure impacts on conversion, retention, and revenue
- Iterate based on findings
Slack regularly tests pricing variants with new customer cohorts, allowing them to optimize pricing while maintaining stability for existing customers.
Leveraging AI for More Sophisticated Pricing
The emergence of AI pricing tools presents new opportunities for SaaS companies to optimize their value-based approaches. Modern AI solutions can:
- Analyze vast amounts of customer usage data to identify value patterns
- Predict price sensitivity across different segments
- Recommend optimal pricing tiers and feature bundling
- Forecast the revenue impact of pricing changes
According to a 2022 study by McKinsey, SaaS companies using AI-powered pricing tools achieve 3-8% higher revenue compared to those using traditional pricing methods. AI helps identify value patterns that might be invisible to even the most experienced pricing teams.
Making the Transition from Competitor to Value-Based Pricing
If you're currently using competitor-based pricing, here's how to begin the transition:
- Start with research: Conduct customer interviews focused on value perception, not price points
- Quantify your differential value: Calculate the tangible benefits your solution provides compared to alternatives
- Test incrementally: Begin with new customer segments rather than changing pricing for existing customers
- Communicate value clearly: Update your messaging to emphasize value metrics over feature lists
- Train your sales team: Equip them to have value-based conversations rather than price-focused negotiations
Conclusion
Breaking free from competitor-based SaaS pricing isn't just a strategic choice—it's increasingly becoming a necessity for sustainable growth. As markets mature and competition intensifies, the companies that thrive will be those that deeply understand and effectively capture the unique value they provide.
The shift to value-based pricing requires investment in customer research, willingness to experiment, and the courage to stand apart from competitors. But the rewards—higher margins, better product-market fit, and more resilient growth—make it well worth the effort. In the words of pricing expert Patrick Campbell, "The biggest pricing mistake SaaS companies make is not spending enough time on pricing."
Rather than asking "What are our competitors charging?" start with "What value are we delivering, and how can our pricing reflect that?" Your bottom line will thank you.