How Should You Price Your SaaS Product? One-time Payment vs. Subscription Models

December 8, 2025

Get Started with Pricing Strategy Consulting

Join companies like Zoom, DocuSign, and Twilio using our systematic pricing approach to increase revenue by 12-40% year-over-year.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
How Should You Price Your SaaS Product? One-time Payment vs. Subscription Models

This article expands on a question originally shared by GloriusFlorius on Reddit — enhanced with additional analysis and frameworks.

Choosing the right pricing model for your SaaS product can make or break your business. When you're targeting different customer segments with varying usage patterns, it's especially challenging to find a pricing approach that satisfies everyone while generating sustainable revenue.

For SaaS founders building niche tools like event scheduling platforms, this dilemma becomes even more pronounced. Should you go with a freemium model, charge one-time fees, implement a subscription, or create a hybrid approach? Let's examine the optimal pricing strategy based on real-world SaaS pricing patterns.

Understanding Your Users' Needs First

Before deciding on a pricing model, it's crucial to understand that most niche SaaS products typically serve two distinct user groups with different needs:

  1. Occasional users (1-2 uses per year) who resist recurring payments
  2. Regular users (frequent/ongoing usage) who prefer predictable subscription billing

In the case of an event scheduling platform, these segments translate to:

  • One-off festival or retreat organizers who run events infrequently
  • Studios, schools, or organizations that regularly host workshops or classes

A common mistake SaaS founders make is forcing a single pricing model onto both groups, which inevitably alienates one segment or the other.

The Four Main SaaS Pricing Approaches

Let's examine the four most common pricing approaches for niche SaaS products:

1. Freemium Model (Free With Limitations)

Benefits:

  • Low-friction adoption for first-time users
  • Organic word-of-mouth growth potential
  • SEO advantages from wider usage base

Drawbacks:

  • May attract non-converting "hobbyists"
  • Can devalue your product if free tier is too generous
  • Requires converting enough free users to paid to be viable

Analysis of B2B SaaS pricing models shows that freemium works best when you have a clear upgrade trigger that users naturally hit (like storage limits or team collaboration needs).

2. One-Time Fee Per Usage

Benefits:

  • Aligns with occasional users' mental model
  • No subscription anxiety for infrequent users
  • Simpler purchasing decision (no ongoing commitment)

Drawbacks:

  • Unpredictable revenue (feast or famine cycles)
  • Requires constant new customer acquisition
  • Lower lifetime value than subscription models

Industry data reveals that one-time fees work well for tools with clear "per-project" use cases but struggle to support ongoing product development and customer support.

3. Subscription-Only Model

Benefits:

  • Predictable recurring revenue
  • Higher lifetime value per customer
  • Easier financial planning and growth forecasting

Drawbacks:

  • Scares away occasional or small-scale users
  • Higher psychological barrier to initial purchase
  • May feel expensive for seasonal businesses

Our analysis of SaaS pricing transitions shows that pure subscription models work best for products used on a truly regular basis, but create friction for intermittent users.

4. Hybrid Pricing Model

Benefits:

  • Captures both occasional and regular user segments
  • Provides natural upgrade path as usage increases
  • Allows users to choose what fits their needs

Drawbacks:

  • More complex to communicate and implement
  • Requires managing multiple revenue streams
  • May cannibalize between pricing tiers if not structured properly

Based on our research of pricing models across numerous SaaS verticals, hybrid pricing shows the highest success rate for products serving mixed usage patterns.

The Optimal Pricing Strategy for Niche SaaS Tools

For specialized SaaS tools like an event scheduling platform, the data strongly suggests that a hybrid model provides the optimal balance between adoption and revenue. A three-tiered approach typically works best:

1. Free Tier (Limited but Functional)

  • One published event with core functionality
  • Branding/watermark included
  • Basic analytics
  • Limited features (but enough to be genuinely useful)

2. Per-Event Pass (€29-69 per event)

  • Complete functionality for a single event
  • Branded experience (remove watermarks)
  • Full analytics
  • All premium features
  • Perfect for one-off events or occasional organizers

3. Pro Subscription (€15-25/month or €149/year)

  • Multiple events (5+ per year)
  • Complete white-labeling
  • Advanced analytics
  • Team access
  • Priority support
  • Ideal for studios, schools and regular organizers

This structure addresses both core user segments while creating natural upgrade paths based on actual usage patterns. The free tier provides a no-risk entry point, while the per-event option satisfies occasional users and the subscription caters to regular organizers.

Implementation Tips for Your Hybrid Pricing Model

Based on extensive pricing case studies across SaaS companies, here are practical tips for implementing a hybrid model effectively:

1. Keep Your Value Metric Clear

Choose a primary value metric (in this case, "number of events") that clearly correlates with the value users receive. Make this the foundation of your pricing tiers.

2. Start Simple with Pricing Technology

Don't overengineer your metering systems. Begin with basic per-event SKUs and a subscription toggle. You can add more sophisticated metering later as you grow.

3. A/B Test Critical Price Points

Test different price points for your per-event fees (€29 vs €49 vs €69) and different monthly vs. annual discounts for subscriptions (10% vs. 20% annual discount).

4. Track Key Conversion Metrics

Monitor these essential metrics:

  • Free-to-paid conversion rate
  • Average events per account
  • Subscription retention/churn
  • Revenue per customer

5. Add Enterprise Options Later

Once you've validated your core pricing, you can introduce custom enterprise pricing for larger organizations with special needs (API access, deep integrations, dedicated support).

Real-World Examples That Support This Approach

Companies across various niches have succeeded with similar hybrid approaches:

  1. Event management platforms like Sched offer both per-event pricing and subscriptions for frequent organizers
  2. Design tools like Canva provide free usage with per-design purchasing or subscription options
  3. Project management tools like ClickUp offer free plans with per-seat pricing or subscription options

Examining these success stories reveals a pattern: they all allow users to "buy the way they want to buy" rather than forcing a single pricing model.

Conclusion: Match Your Pricing to User Behavior

The most successful SaaS pricing strategies align with how users naturally interact with your product. For tools with mixed usage patterns like event scheduling platforms, a hybrid approach with free, per-usage, and subscription options creates the lowest barrier to adoption while maximizing revenue opportunities.

Instead of forcing all users into a subscription model or leaving money on the table with only per-event pricing, the three-tiered hybrid model gives each customer segment what they want. This approach also creates natural upsell paths as customers' needs evolve.

Remember that pricing is never set in stone—the most successful SaaS companies continuously iterate on their pricing strategy based on customer feedback and usage data. Start with a thoughtful hybrid approach, measure results carefully, and adjust based on what you learn from real customers.

Get Started with Pricing Strategy Consulting

Join companies like Zoom, DocuSign, and Twilio using our systematic pricing approach to increase revenue by 12-40% year-over-year.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.