.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In the rapidly evolving insurtech landscape, Managing General Agents (MGAs) offering SaaS solutions face a common pricing dilemma: how to create attractive pricing tiers for different customer segments while protecting the value of premium enterprise plans. The challenge is significant—design your tiers too generously, and larger clients might downgrade; price them too restrictively, and you'll struggle to attract and retain smaller clients.
Let's explore strategies insurtech MGAs can implement to develop a pricing structure that maximizes revenue across all customer segments while preventing cannibalization of higher-tier plans.
Understanding the Insurtech MGA SaaS Pricing Challenge
Insurtech MGAs occupy a unique position in the insurance value chain. As technology-enabled underwriters with delegated authority from carriers, they need pricing strategies that reflect both their specialized offerings and their operational model.
According to a 2023 McKinsey report, SaaS companies that effectively implement multi-tiered pricing strategies see 30% higher revenue growth compared to those with simpler pricing models. However, for insurtech MGAs, the stakes are particularly high when balancing between SMB accessibility and enterprise value protection.
The Foundation: Value-Based Pricing Over Cost-Plus
Before establishing tiers, insurtech MGAs should adopt a value-based pricing approach rather than cost-plus pricing. This requires understanding how different customer segments perceive value.
"Value-based pricing strategies allow insurtech MGAs to capture more revenue by aligning pricing with the actual business outcomes customers experience," notes Andrew Chen, partner at Andreessen Horowitz, in his analysis of SaaS pricing models.
A thorough value-based approach requires:
- Customer interviews across segments to understand perceived value
- Competitive analysis of other insurtech platforms
- Quantification of ROI for different customer types
- Understanding of how usage correlates with value realization
Effective Price Fences for Insurtech MGAs
Price fences are the features, limitations, or conditions that separate one pricing tier from another. For insurtech MGAs, establishing clear and legitimate price fences is essential to prevent cannibalization.
Technical Price Fences
- API call volume limitations: Restrict the number of programmatic interactions for lower tiers
- Data processing capabilities: Limit the volume or frequency of underwriting data processing
- Integration options: Reserve premium carrier integrations for enterprise tiers
- Environment options: Offer more testing/staging environments at higher tiers
- SOX compliance features: Reserve advanced compliance reporting for enterprise clients
Feature-Based Price Fences
- Underwriting customization: Offer greater rule customization at higher tiers
- Analytics depth: Provide basic reporting at lower tiers, advanced analytics at higher tiers
- Automation capabilities: Reserve complex automation workflows for enterprise clients
- Multi-carrier options: Limit the number of carrier connections in lower tiers
- White-labeling: Reserve for enterprise tiers only
Service-Level Price Fences
- Implementation support: Basic for lower tiers, white-glove for enterprise
- Response time SLAs: 24/7 support for enterprise, business hours only for lower tiers
- Account management: Dedicated resources only at higher tiers
- Training and enablement: Self-serve vs. personalized training sessions
- Professional services: Advanced advisory services for enterprise clients only
Implementing Usage-Based Pricing Elements
Usage-based pricing has gained significant traction in SaaS, with OpenView Partners' 2022 SaaS Benchmarks Report showing that companies with usage-based models grow 38% faster than their counterparts with purely subscription-based pricing.
For insurtech MGAs, effective usage-based pricing metrics might include:
- Policy volume: Tiered pricing based on the number of policies underwritten
- Premium volume: Pricing that scales with the total premium processed
- User seats: Limiting the number of platform users at each tier
- Transaction volume: Pricing based on the number of quotes, binds, or endorsements
Psychological Pricing Strategies to Minimize Cannibalization
Beyond feature differentiation, psychological pricing tactics can help protect enterprise plans:
The Good-Better-Best Approach
Offer three primary tiers with clear value progression:
- Good: Basic underwriting capabilities for small MGAs
- Better: Enhanced features targeting mid-market MGAs
- Best: Comprehensive enterprise offering
Anchoring with a Premium "Platinum" Tier
Create an ultra-premium tier that makes the enterprise plan seem more reasonable by comparison, even if few customers adopt the highest tier.
Transparent Discounting Framework
Develop a clear enterprise discounting structure that adheres to SOX compliance requirements while providing sales teams guidelines for larger deals without undermining your pricing integrity.
A 2022 study by Price Intelligently found that companies with documented discounting frameworks experienced 15% less revenue leakage than those without clear policies.
Creating Targeted Package Names and Positioning
Package naming can subtly communicate intended audiences:
- Startup: For emerging MGAs (limited by funding stage or age)
- Growth: For established MGAs expanding their programs
- Scale: For mid-market MGAs with multiple programs
- Enterprise: For large MGAs with complex needs
Each name signals who the tier is for, making it psychologically harder for enterprise clients to justify choosing lower tiers.
Transition Strategies for Growing Clients
Creating clear migration paths from lower to higher tiers is essential:
- Usage monitoring alerts: Notify customers as they approach tier limits
- Success-based triggers: Identify usage patterns that indicate readiness for upgrade
- Time-limited tier trials: Allow temporary access to higher-tier features
- Growth incentives: Offer short-term discounts when upgrading to higher tiers
Testing Your Pricing Structure
Before fully implementing your tiered strategy, consider:
- A/B testing different tier configurations: Test various feature allocations with new prospects
- Customer advisory feedback: Get input from existing clients across segments
- Win/loss analysis: Review deals won and lost to identify pricing patterns
- Competitive shopping: Evaluate how competitors structure their tiers
Conclusion: Balance is Key
Effective pricing tier design for insurtech MGAs requires balancing accessibility for smaller clients while preserving compelling value propositions for enterprise customers. By implementing strategic price fences, value-based pricing metrics, and clear positioning, MGAs can create pricing structures that grow with their clients rather than encouraging them to game the system.
The most successful insurtech MGAs recognize that pricing is not static—it requires continuous evaluation and refinement as market conditions, competitive pressures, and customer needs evolve. By establishing a framework that clearly communicates value across segments while protecting premium offerings, you can build a pricing strategy that drives sustainable growth across your entire customer base.