.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
The Silent Killer of Startup Potential
As a new CEO, you've poured countless hours into developing your SaaS product. You've refined features, fixed bugs, and built something truly valuable. Yet when it comes time to set prices, hesitation creeps in. "Maybe we should start low to gain traction," you think. "We're new—who would pay premium prices for our solution?"
This reflexive undervaluing is perhaps one of the most common—and costly—mistakes in the startup world. According to a study by McKinsey & Company, a mere 1% price improvement can yield an 11% increase in operating profits for the average company. For cash-conscious startups, proper pricing isn't just important—it's existential.
Why Founders Chronically Underprice
The psychology behind startup underpricing is multifaceted:
Fear of Rejection
First-time founders often equate higher prices with higher risk of rejection. According to Price Intelligently, 80% of SaaS startups admit to using "gut feeling" rather than data to set initial prices. This emotionally-driven approach typically skews toward underpricing as a perceived safety net.
The "We're Not Established Yet" Fallacy
Many founders believe they must "earn" the right to charge premium prices through years of market presence. This fundamentally misunderstands how customers evaluate value. As Patrick Campbell of ProfitWell notes, "Customers don't care about your tenure; they care about how well you solve their problem."
Overestimating Price Sensitivity
Research from Simon-Kucher & Partners reveals that 72% of SaaS founders significantly overestimate their customers' price sensitivity. While you obsess over a $20 price difference, your enterprise customers may be comparing your solution to alternatives costing tens of thousands more.
The True Cost of Underpricing
When you underprice your product, you're not just leaving money on the table—you're actively sabotaging your startup's future:
Resource Starvation
Low prices mean low margins. Low margins mean limited resources for product development, customer success, and growth initiatives. According to OpenView Partners' 2022 SaaS Benchmarks Report, companies with higher average contract values (ACVs) invest 43% more in R&D and 58% more in customer success than their low-priced counterparts.
Damaged Brand Perception
Price is a powerful signaling mechanism. As behavioral economist Dan Ariely has demonstrated in multiple studies, customers often use price as a proxy for quality. By setting low prices, you're potentially signaling that your solution is less valuable than competitors.
The Uphill Battle of Price Increases
Once you've anchored customers to a price point, significant increases become challenging. Data from ChartMogul indicates that SaaS companies typically achieve only 5-7% price increases during renewals, meaning initial underpricing can haunt your revenue trajectory for years.
Setting Value-Based Prices: A Framework for Startup CEOs
How do you determine the right price? Start with these principles:
1. Calculate Your Value Creation
The most successful SaaS companies price based on a percentage of the value they create for customers. Examples:
- If your solution saves a mid-market company 10 hours of employee time per week (roughly $500), capturing 10-20% of that value ($50-100/week) would be reasonable.
- If your software helps increase conversion rates by 0.5% for an e-commerce site doing $5M in annual revenue ($25,000 in additional revenue), pricing at $5,000-10,000 annually represents significant ROI.
2. Segment Your Market Intentionally
Different customer segments derive different value from your solution. Zoom's tiered pricing model is exemplary here, with free personal plans, $149/year professional plans, and custom enterprise pricing that can reach hundreds of thousands annually—each aligned with segment-specific value.
3. Consider Value Metrics Over Flat Fees
According to OpenView Partners, SaaS companies that price using value metrics (e.g., per user, per transaction, per GB) grow 38% faster than those using flat subscription fees. These metrics align your revenue with the value customers receive, creating natural expansion paths.
4. Test Multiple Price Points
Rather than guessing, implement structured price testing. Salesforce famously tested three price points simultaneously in their early days, discovering that their highest tier had similar conversion rates to their lowest—instantly boosting revenue by 300% for one-third of new customers.
Supporting Higher Prices Through Value Communication
Once you've established value-based prices, you must effectively communicate that value:
Build Compelling ROI Calculators
Demonstrating concrete ROI makes price concerns secondary. DocuSign's ROI calculator shows potential customers they'll save $36 per document by eliminating paper processes—making their pricing seem trivial in comparison.
Leverage Social Proof Strategically
Case studies should prominently highlight value metrics. Rather than vague testimonials, showcase specific outcomes: "Company X increased lead conversion by 32% within 60 days, generating $430,000 in additional revenue."
Train Your Team on Value Selling
According to Corporate Visions research, only 14% of sales conversations focus on the unique value the company provides. Ensure your team can articulate why your solution commands premium pricing through concrete value discussions.
When to Consider Strategic Discounting
Strategic discounting differs fundamentally from underpricing:
- Annual pre-payment discounts: Offering 10-15% off for annual payments improves cash flow without permanently devaluing your product.
- Limited-time adoption incentives: Early-bird or implementation discounts that expire create urgency while maintaining long-term price integrity.
- Volume-based efficiency discounts: Discounts aligned with genuine economies of scale preserve perceived value.
The CEO's Pricing Mindset
As CEO, your confidence in pricing sets the tone company-wide. Adopt these mindset principles:
Your expertise has tangible value. The years spent understanding your industry and building your solution are worth charging for.
Your job is to maximize stakeholder outcomes, not minimize customer costs. Fair pricing ensures you can deliver exceptional experiences to customers, returns to investors, and opportunities to employees.
Price is a product feature. It should be designed with the same care as your user interface or feature set.
Taking Action Today
If you suspect you're underpricing, consider these immediate steps:
- Survey existing customers about perceived value (not about pricing directly).
- Implement tiered pricing if you haven't already.
- Establish a higher-priced tier for new features or premium support.
- Test price increases with new customers while grandfathering existing ones.
Remember that pricing is an evolving strategy, not a one-time decision. The most successful SaaS companies revisit pricing quarterly, making data-driven adjustments as their product and market evolve.
Your product represents years of innovation, problem-solving, and expertise. Price it accordingly, and you'll build not just a product, but a sustainable business that can continue delivering value for years to come.