.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In today's competitive SaaS landscape, implementing a price matching policy can be a powerful tool for customer acquisition and retention. However, before rolling out such a policy company-wide, systematic testing is essential to ensure it delivers the intended results without compromising revenue or brand positioning.
Why Test Your SaaS Price Matching Policy?
Price matching policies in SaaS differ significantly from retail implementations. While retail price matching is straightforward—match a competitor's lower price on an identical product—SaaS offerings typically vary in features, implementation, support levels, and overall value proposition.
According to a study by ProfitWell, 20% of SaaS companies that implemented untested price matching policies saw negative impacts on their overall revenue, despite increased customer acquisition rates. This disconnect highlights why thorough testing is critical before full implementation.
Establishing Clear Price Matching Parameters
Before testing begins, define precisely what your price matching will cover:
- Feature-to-feature matching: Will you match only when competitors offer identical functionality?
- Match duration: Is this a one-time match or for the duration of the subscription?
- Qualifying competitors: Which specific competitors will trigger your price match?
- Verification requirements: What evidence will customers need to provide?
- Application process: How will customers request and receive the match?
"The most successful SaaS price matching policies have clearly defined boundaries," notes Patrick Campbell, CEO of ProfitWell. "Without them, you're essentially giving away your pricing power."
Designing Your Price Matching Policy Tests
1. Segmented Cohort Testing
Rather than testing across your entire customer base, create specific customer segments for controlled experiments:
- New customer segment: Measure acquisition rate changes when price matching is offered during onboarding
- Renewal risk segment: Test with customers approaching renewal who have mentioned competitive pricing
- Enterprise vs. SMB segments: Evaluate different responses based on company size
Salesforce found that price matching effectiveness varied dramatically across customer segments, with a 32% higher retention impact on enterprise customers compared to small business accounts.
2. Time-Bound Tests
Implement your price matching test for a specific timeframe to gather data without long-term commitment:
- 30-day price match guarantee: Offer matching for the first month to capture immediate competitive responses
- Quarterly test periods: Run tests that align with your financial reporting periods for cleaner analysis
- Seasonal tests: Test during high competitive pressure periods in your industry
3. Regional Testing
For global SaaS companies, regional markets often have different competitive dynamics:
- Test in high-competition markets first
- Compare results across regions with varying competitive landscapes
- Adjust policies based on regional price sensitivity differences
Measuring Price Matching Test Results
Effective measurement requires tracking multiple metrics beyond simple conversion rates:
Essential Metrics to Track
- Conversion rate impact: How does price matching affect your close rate?
- Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Does price matching reduce or increase your CAC?
- Customer Lifetime Value (LTV): Do price-matched customers remain loyal long-term?
- Competitive win rate: Track wins specifically against competitors included in your matching policy
- Average discount depth: What's the average percentage match provided?
- Price match request volume: How many customers actually request matches?
- Support/sales team time investment: How much staff time goes into processing match requests?
"The most revealing metric is often the gap between how many customers cite price as a decision factor and how many actually request a match when offered," explains April Dunford, positioning expert and author of "Obviously Awesome."
Common SaaS Price Matching Test Pitfalls
1. Ignoring Operational Impact
Price matching policies create operational requirements that must be accounted for during testing:
- Sales team training requirements
- Verification process development
- Financial approval workflows
- CRM integration for tracking
2. Undermining Value-Based Pricing
According to a 2022 OpenView Partners survey, 68% of SaaS companies are focused on value-based pricing strategies. Price matching tests must be designed to complement, not contradict, your value proposition.
"When you immediately jump to matching a competitor's price, you're tacitly admitting your product isn't differentiated enough to command its own price point," cautions Lincoln Murphy, customer success strategist.
3. Creating Unsustainable Expectations
Price matching can accidentally create expectations that become difficult to manage at scale:
- Customers expecting continued matches at each renewal
- Prospects intentionally shopping competitive offers to trigger matches
- Competitors potentially manipulating pricing to force responses
Crafting a Successful Test Framework
Based on data from successful SaaS price matching implementations, here's a framework for effective testing:
- Define success metrics upfront: Establish specific KPIs that would constitute a successful test
- Create clear documentation: Develop internal and customer-facing documentation for consistency
- Establish competitive intelligence protocols: Ensure your team can quickly verify competitor pricing claims
- Train customer-facing teams thoroughly: Sales and support need complete understanding of test parameters
- Implement robust tracking systems: Ensure your CRM can capture all price matching activities
- Schedule regular analysis points: Review results at predetermined intervals
- Prepare multiple follow-up scenarios: Have plans ready for both successful and unsuccessful tests
Real-World Examples of Successful Implementation
Case Study: Enterprise SaaS Provider
A leading enterprise analytics platform implemented a targeted price matching test for mid-market customers approaching renewal who mentioned switching to a specific competitor.
Results:
- 24% increase in renewal rates in the test segment
- 4% decrease in average revenue per account
- Net positive impact on retention revenue
Their key finding: Price matching was most effective when combined with feature education, as many customers weren't fully utilizing the platform's differentiating capabilities.
Case Study: SMB Subscription Service
A small business marketing automation provider tested a "110% match" guarantee (offering 10% below any verified competitor price) for new customers in high-competition regions.
Results:
- 18% increase in conversion rate
- 22% increase in CAC
- Break-even after 14 months
Their conclusion: The increased acquisition was valuable in specific markets but required improved onboarding to accelerate time-to-value and improve economics.
Conclusion: Building Pricing Strategy Resilience
Price matching policy tests, when properly executed, provide valuable insights beyond the immediate question of whether to implement matching. They reveal customer price sensitivity, competitive positioning opportunities, and potential weaknesses in your value communication.
The most successful SaaS companies use these tests not just to decide on price matching, but to strengthen their overall pricing optimization strategy and market positioning. By taking a methodical approach to testing, you can determine whether price matching belongs in your competitive toolkit while gathering intelligence that improves your pricing approach regardless of the test outcome.
Remember: effective price matching in SaaS isn't about being the cheapest option—it's about removing price as an obstacle for customers who already recognize your unique value.