.png)
Frameworks, core principles and top case studies for SaaS pricing, learnt and refined over 28+ years of SaaS-monetization experience.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
In the rapidly evolving SaaS landscape, finding the optimal pricing structure can be the difference between sustainable growth and stagnation. While many SaaS leaders focus intensely on product development and marketing, pricing strategy often remains an afterthought. Yet, testing your pricing against competitors can unlock significant revenue potential and market positioning advantages. This article explores the benefits and potential pitfalls of competitive SaaS pricing tests, helping you navigate this strategic terrain with confidence.
Why Competitive Pricing Matters in SaaS
The subscription economy has fundamentally changed how customers perceive value. Unlike one-time purchases, SaaS customers continuously evaluate whether your solution justifies its recurring cost. According to a Price Intelligently study, a mere 1% improvement in pricing strategy can yield an 11% increase in profit—significantly higher than the impact of a 1% improvement in customer acquisition or retention.
Competitive pricing benchmarking serves as a critical component of your broader pricing strategy. It provides:
- Market context for your value proposition
- Insights into customer expectations
- A framework for positioning your solution within the competitive landscape
- Data-driven foundations for pricing decisions
The Benefits of Testing Your Pricing Against Competitors
Market Positioning Clarity
Conducting thorough market research around pricing helps you understand where your product sits in the competitive landscape. Are you a premium solution commanding higher subscription pricing, or are you disrupting the market with an aggressive entry point?
According to research by Simon-Kucher & Partners, companies that regularly conduct pricing research outperform their peers by 25% in terms of profit generation.
Customer Perception Insights
Pricing isn't just about numbers—it's a powerful communication tool. When HubSpot shifted from a complex pricing model to a simpler tiered structure based on competitive analysis, they saw a 25% increase in conversion rates. The pricing change signaled value and transparency to prospective customers who previously found their model confusing compared to competitors.
Pricing Optimization Opportunities
Competitive benchmarking often reveals underpriced features or services. One enterprise SaaS company discovered through competitive pricing tests that they were charging 40% less than competitors for premium support, despite offering superior service levels. After adjusting their pricing strategy, they increased annual recurring revenue by 15% with minimal customer pushback.
Market Gap Identification
Strategic pricing research frequently uncovers untapped market segments. For example, Slack identified a gap between free tools and enterprise solutions, allowing them to craft a pricing strategy that captured small-to-medium businesses previously underserved by competitors.
The Potential Pitfalls of Competitive Pricing Tests
Ignoring Value Differentiators
Perhaps the greatest risk in competitive pricing benchmarking is focusing solely on price points without accounting for value differences. Your product might include features that justify premium pricing, or it might lack capabilities that warrant a discount compared to competitors.
Triggering Destructive Price Wars
When Zendesk attempted to revise their pricing strategy based purely on competitive positioning in 2013, they faced significant backlash from customers. According to former CEO Mikkel Svane, the approach "undervalued our own worth and triggered unnecessary price sensitivity in the market."
Overlooking Total Cost of Ownership
Subscription pricing is just one element of the total cost equation for customers. Implementation costs, training requirements, and integration capabilities all factor into the actual expense of adopting your solution. Competitive tests that ignore these factors provide incomplete data.
Creating Internal Resistance
Price changes stemming from competitive analysis often face resistance from sales teams concerned about closing deals or customer success teams worried about retention. According to Forrester Research, over 60% of pricing initiatives fail due to poor internal alignment rather than market factors.
How to Conduct Effective Competitive Pricing Tests
1. Define Your True Competitors
Not every SaaS solution in your general category is a direct competitor. Segment your analysis based on:
- Target customer profiles
- Feature parity
- Market positioning
- Geographic focus
2. Look Beyond Published Prices
Published rates rarely tell the complete story. Effective pricing benchmarking should investigate:
- Discount structures
- Contract length options
- Bundling strategies
- Add-on and expansion pricing
- Enterprise agreement terms
3. Incorporate Value Metrics
According to OpenView Partners' 2022 SaaS Metrics Report, 58% of successful SaaS companies price primarily on value metrics (usage or outcome-based pricing) rather than just feature access. Competitive pricing tests should account for how competitors measure and capture value.
4. Test Customer Reactions
Theoretical analysis has limits. Consider running A/B tests with:
- Different pricing pages showing competitor-informed structures
- Sales team experiments with new pricing in select territories
- Customer surveys measuring perceived value against presented price points
Finding Balance in Your Pricing Strategy
Effective SaaS pricing optimization strikes a balance between competitive awareness and unique value proposition. Price Intelligently's research suggests the optimal approach involves:
- Starting with your value metrics and cost structure
- Validating with competitive benchmarking
- Testing with actual customer feedback
- Iterating based on market response
Conclusion: Strategic Pricing as Competitive Advantage
Competitive SaaS pricing tests provide valuable market context, but they shouldn't dictate your entire pricing strategy. The most successful SaaS companies view pricing as a strategic lever that communicates value, targets ideal customers, and supports sustainable growth.
By understanding both the benefits and limitations of competitive pricing analysis, you can develop a pricing optimization approach that positions your solution effectively while avoiding the pitfalls of market-following behavior.
Remember that pricing strategy isn't a one-time exercise—it requires ongoing refinement as your product evolves, your market matures, and customer expectations shift. The companies that excel at pricing strategy typically revisit their approaches quarterly and conduct deep competitive analyses annually to maintain their edge in this critical business dimension.