.png)
Estd 4.22.2023
Introduction
In the competitive SaaS landscape, the temptation to slash prices to attract more customers is ever-present. The strategy seems logical on its surface: lower your price point, capture more market share, and scale your way to success. However, this volume-focused approach often overlooks a critical business truth—not all customers contribute equally to sustainable growth. In fact, pursuing customer volume at the expense of customer value can lead to damaging long-term consequences for SaaS companies, from eroded profit margins to diminished brand perception.
This article examines why the "race to the bottom" pricing strategy frequently backfires, and offers alternative approaches for SaaS executives looking to build lasting value in their organizations.
The Allure of the Volume Game
The volume-over-value approach has an undeniable appeal, particularly for emerging SaaS companies eager to demonstrate growth to investors or stakeholders.
Perceived Benefits of Price-Driven Volume
Rapid customer acquisition: Lower price points can accelerate adoption rates, particularly in price-sensitive segments.
Market share expansion: Undercutting competitors may help capture a larger percentage of the available market.
Vanity metrics improvement: Customer count and revenue growth often look impressive in the short term.
According to OpenView Partners' 2022 SaaS Benchmarks report, 64% of early-stage SaaS companies have experimented with reducing prices to drive growth at some point in their journey. Yet the same report indicates that companies pursuing this strategy often experience difficulties sustaining that growth beyond 18-24 months.
The Hidden Costs of Chasing Volume
The rush to acquire customers through discounted pricing comes with significant downsides that may not be immediately apparent but compound over time.
Margin Compression
When SaaS companies compete primarily on price, they inevitably compress their margins. According to data from ProfitWell, SaaS companies that consistently discount see 30% lower profit margins compared to those that maintain pricing integrity.
This margin compression has cascading effects:
- Reduced resources for product development
- Limited ability to provide high-quality customer support
- Decreased investment in innovation and differentiation
- Constrained marketing budgets for future growth
Attracting the Wrong Customer Base
Perhaps more concerning is the type of customer typically acquired through low-price strategies. Price-sensitive customers often exhibit several problematic characteristics:
Higher churn rates: Customers attracted primarily by low prices show 3-4x higher churn rates than those who purchase based on value, according to Chartered Institute of Marketing research.
Lower expansion potential: Customers who prioritize cost-savings over value typically spend 40% less on upsells and cross-sells over their lifetime.
Increased support demands: Paradoxically, price-sensitive customers often require more support while contributing less to the bottom line. ServiceNow's benchmark data suggests these customers generate 35% more support tickets per dollar of revenue.
Commoditization Risk
When companies compete primarily on price, they inadvertently train their market to view their offering as a commodity rather than a differentiated solution. This reinforces the idea that all solutions in the category are essentially interchangeable, with price being the primary differentiator.
As Jason Lemkin, founder of SaaStr, notes: "Competing on price in SaaS is treacherous. You're essentially telling the market your product isn't worth paying full price for."
Case Study: The Pricing Correction
Consider the experience of Atlassian, which initially gained traction with relatively low-priced developer tools. As they expanded their product suite and enterprise capabilities, they faced significant challenges in raising prices to reflect their true value. Their 2015 transition to value-based pricing initially faced customer backlash but ultimately led to healthier growth.
By 2022, Atlassian's average revenue per customer had increased by over 120%, while their churn rate decreased by 15%. This pricing strategy shift contributed significantly to their ability to sustain a 30%+ growth rate year over year, even as they approached $2 billion in annual revenue.
The Value-First Alternative
Rather than competing on price, successful SaaS companies are increasingly adopting value-based approaches that balance acquisition with profitability.
Strategies for Value-Based Growth
Segment-specific pricing: Create pricing tiers that address specific customer segments with tailored feature sets, rather than competing across the board with low prices.
Value-based messaging: Focus marketing on ROI and outcomes rather than product features or price points. According to Gartner, companies that emphasize business value in their messaging see 24% higher win rates.
Customer success investment: Reallocate resources from acquisition to retention and expansion. Research from Bain & Company shows that a 5% increase in customer retention can increase profits by 25-95%.
Strategic discounting: Use discounts as a tactical tool for specific situations rather than as an overall strategy. Time-limited promotions, expansion incentives, or high-volume enterprise deals can utilize discounts without eroding your core value proposition.
Building a Sustainable Value Proposition
The most successful SaaS companies have learned to resist the volume trap by developing robust value propositions that justify premium pricing.
Key Components of a Sustainable Value Proposition:
Quantifiable outcomes: Help prospects understand the specific ROI they can expect from your solution.
Unique capabilities: Highlight differentiated features that directly address customer pain points in ways competitors cannot match.
Customer success stories: Leverage social proof through case studies that document tangible value creation for similar customers.
Implementation support: Offer onboarding and integration assistance that ensures customers realize value quickly.
According to research from PwC's Digital IQ study, companies that effectively communicate and deliver on their value proposition command prices 16-22% higher than competitors and enjoy customer retention rates approximately 38% higher.
Conclusion
The pursuit of customer volume at the expense of customer value represents a dangerous trap for SaaS companies. While lower prices may deliver short-term growth, they often lead to compressed margins, higher churn, increased support costs, and market commoditization that undermines long-term success.
By shifting focus from pure volume to customer value—through segment-specific pricing, value-based messaging, customer success investment, and strategic discounting—SaaS companies can build sustainable businesses that maintain pricing power while delivering meaningful outcomes to customers.
The most successful SaaS leaders recognize that not every customer is the right customer, and that sustainable growth comes not from having the most customers, but from having the right customers who recognize and are willing to pay for the value you provide. In the long run, this approach not only produces healthier financial outcomes but also creates the foundation for continued innovation and market leadership.